They spent the evening with figures spread across the table. It turned out the idea was not foolish, merely complicated. If Ethan leased a small warehouse in town for feed and supplies, his trips could be reduced, and he could spend two or three nights each week near Bracken Ford during winter. Otis was capable of overseeing the cattle for short periods, though he would require a higher wage and another hired hand. No one would get everything they wanted, but there might be a path that left both businesses standing.
Clara heard nothing of these calculations. She was busy at the boarding house, where the first attempt to repair the roof without borrowing money had begun. She and Matthew Dawson carried bundles of worn shingles down from the shed while Eliza inspected the rafters. The work went slowly. Mrs. Porter suggested asking the school trustees whether the shed could be used for winter storage in exchange for help with repairs. The suggestion had merit because the school was expanding its winter coal supply and needed a dry place to keep it. Clara agreed to speak with the trustees the following week.
She had never considered that her community might value the shed for something other than her own stores. The possibility reminded her that the boarding house had always been more than a private business. Travelers received meals there, people without families shared a table there, and the town's solitary residents found a place where someone noticed if they failed to return at supper. She had built that quiet center without naming it. The prospect of losing it because of a rumor now felt more painful than the loss of income alone.
On Wednesday evening Caleb arrived with the coins he had promised. Two strangers stood in the sitting room inspecting the bedrooms, a Mr. Edmund Vale and a Mr. Samuel Price, cattle buyers traveling together but not friends. Clara had received word that the rooms might interest them, and she needed the booking. Caleb saw the visitors through the open doorway and offered to return later.
"You said Wednesday before supper," Clara answered. "You're here when you promised."
He took off his hat, counted the coins into her hand, and waited while she entered them in the ledger. Vale recognized his name and remarked that he was the fellow who had been dragged out of a saloon. Caleb flushed. Clara told the buyer there had been no fight, but he seemed determined to hear the more colorful version. For once Caleb did not look away.
"I'd been drinking, sir," he said. "I tried to drive Mrs. Whitfield's wagon. The bridge was damaged, and she stopped me before I could hurt the horse or myself."
"And the wages?" Vale asked.
"I let another man believe the argument was about my pay. It wasn't. I owe her an advance for work I didn't complete. That's what I'm repaying now."
Clara closed the ledger. Vale examined them both. He had traveled enough to distrust any inn that appeared to invite conflict to its doorstep. He commented that a respectable boarding house ought to avoid such trouble. Clara took a breath and answered with the only promise she could give truthfully.