room smelled faintly of expensive leather. Grant was standing when Caleb entered. He shook Caleb's hand and offered coffee. Caleb declined, sat in the chair opposite the desk, and placed his folder on his lap. He had imagined the encounter many times; in reality, Grant looked older and more tired than the confident voice on the recording.
Grant began by asking about the fifty cars. Caleb explained that the original inventory had become the starting point for a used-parts supply company serving independent repair shops. Grant said he had read a briefing and was impressed by the early sales. Caleb asked whether Grant had read the original recycling proposal submitted at Westbridge two years earlier. Grant hesitated. He admitted that he had not been aware of the proposal until recently. Caleb told him that the idea had been credited to Martin Vale even though the engineering division had developed it. Grant's jaw tightened. He said the company was reviewing several attribution issues internally. Caleb answered that those issues mattered to the people whose careers had been shaped by them.
Grant moved to the dispute involving Nathaniel Price. He said the company was prepared to negotiate a substantial settlement rather than prolong litigation. Caleb reminded him that Rebecca represented Nathaniel and that any offer belonged with counsel. Grant said he understood but wanted Caleb's personal view. He asked what would satisfy a man who had found documents in a ruined truck and used them to put pressure on a company that once employed him. Caleb set his folder on the desk and answered carefully. He had not used the documents as leverage to obtain a job, a contract, or money. He had preserved them because someone had gone to unusual lengths to make sure the records survived.
Grant leaned back and said there were business reasons the project had been delayed. Caleb acknowledged that. He told Grant that engineers understood technical risks and that companies had a right to make difficult investment decisions. Then he asked why Nathaniel had been given explanations that differed from the internal financial analysis. He asked why the company continued using elements of the research after the original team was dismantled. He asked why former employees were forced to spend years fighting just to establish who had contributed to a design. Grant did not answer immediately. He looked toward the window, where traffic moved far below like water through a narrow channel.
Eventually Grant said that large organizations made imperfect decisions, and that no leader could personally examine every technical disagreement. Caleb agreed, then asked who was responsible for creating a system in which inconvenient information could be buried without reaching the people empowered to challenge it. Grant looked back at him. He said Caleb was asking him to accept responsibility for things he had not done personally. Caleb answered that responsibility was not the same as blame. It was the obligation that came with the authority to prevent harm, especially when warnings had reached the executive level and been dismissed.