That afternoon, after Lucy went home, Caleb found a drawing taped inside the shed. It showed fifty cars in neat rows, a tiny red truck with a smiling face, and three stick figures standing under a sun. The labels beneath the figures read DAD, OWEN, and ME. Claire had visited often enough by then that Lucy added a fourth figure in the corner, but she left it unlabeled. Caleb recognized the figure by the stack of papers in its hands. He folded the drawing carefully, then changed his mind and put it where everyone could see it. For the first time, the shed looked like something more than a temporary business space.
The first formal warning arrived in a heavy white envelope bearing Westbridge Automotive's legal letterhead. It accused Caleb's company of interfering with contractual supplier relationships and warned that possession or dissemination of proprietary research materials might expose him to serious claims. The letter did not identify the specific conduct it alleged he had committed. Rebecca reviewed it, told him not to respond personally, and sent a careful answer through counsel. She demanded preservation of relevant records and rejected the suggestion that Caleb had improperly obtained documents. The company replied with a shorter letter, less aggressive in tone but no more informative. Caleb placed both letters in a folder and returned to the yard, where a customer was waiting for a replacement transmission control unit.
The legal threat frightened him in a way Grant's laughter never had. Laughter could be ignored. A corporation's lawyers could consume years and money even if their claims ultimately failed. Caleb considered whether accepting a quiet payment for the documents might free him to concentrate on the salvage business and his daughter. He never spoke the thought aloud to Nathaniel. Instead, he wrote the numbers on a sheet of paper and stared at them: rent, insurance, utilities, credit payments, wages, delivery expenses, and expected revenue. There was no spare column marked principles. Yet the prospect of selling the evidence away made him feel as if he would be teaching Lucy that the right decision depended entirely on how expensive it became.
Claire's own position grew uncomfortable. After she opened the distribution-pressure inquiry, her supervisor reassigned several files and asked whether her personal relationship with a former employee compromised her objectivity. She acknowledged the possibility of conflict and requested formal recusal where appropriate. A new reviewer took over the inquiry, but she was not satisfied that the company had implemented adequate protections against retaliation. Her supervisor told her that raising the matter repeatedly would damage her prospects. Claire went home, looked around an apartment containing more law books than furniture, and asked herself why she had spent years learning professional ethics if her employer expected her to stop using them when the questions became difficult.
She had grown up in a small town outside Toledo, the daughter of a school librarian and a truck driver. Her father lost his job during a company merger when she was in high school and spent the next year driving delivery routes for considerably less pay. He rarely complained, but