Halfway through class, Ms. Hargrove closed her binder.
"Nora. Come forward."
The room quieted.
Nora looked up.
"Me?"
"Yes, you."
She walked to the front with slow steps.
Ms. Hargrove smiled. "I have noticed that you seem very interested in our piano. You watch it constantly. You even touched it after class last week."
Nora's face went pale.
Several students turned toward the grand piano.
"I wasn't hurting it," Nora whispered.
"I did not say you were. I simply think curiosity should be followed by participation. Since you seem so fascinated, why don't you play something for the class?"
A few students exchanged looks.
Nora froze.
"I'd rather not."
Ms. Hargrove's smile sharpened. "We do not improve by hiding, Nora. Sit down. Play whatever you know."
"I don't want to."
The answer was so quiet that Ms. Hargrove might have let it go if the entire class had not been watching.
Instead, authority became more important than judgment.
"In this classroom, when I give a reasonable instruction, I expect it to be followed. You have spent two weeks staring at that piano. Now you have an opportunity. Unless, of course, you were pretending to understand something you don't."
Claire covered a smile with her hand.
A boy near the window looked uncomfortable.
Nora's breathing changed.
The piano was no longer a memory. It was a trap.
Ms. Hargrove gestured toward the bench. "Go on."
Nora sat.
Her feet barely reached the floor. The bench felt too smooth beneath her. The piano smelled faintly of furniture polish and wood, exactly like the one from her childhood living room after her mother cleaned it on Saturday mornings.
Her hands trembled above the keys.
Someone whispered, "This is going to be bad."
A few students laughed.
Nora stared at the keyboard.
For a moment, she was six years old again, sitting beside Elise during a storm. Rain had rattled against the windows. Thunder had made the lights flicker. Nora had been afraid.
Elise had placed their hands together on the keys.
"Listen," she had said. "You don't have to be louder than the storm. You only have to be honest inside it."
Nora exhaled.
Her hands stopped shaking.
She began with four notes.