In the fall, Hawthorne hired a new music teacher named Mr. Alvarez. On the first day, he moved the grand piano away from the front wall and placed it at an angle where students could gather around it.
"Instruments are not trophies," he said. "They're tools. Tools are supposed to be used."
He created open practice periods twice a week. Students could sign up regardless of skill level.
The first student to sign up was not Nora.
It was the boy Ms. Hargrove had once sighed at for missing a rhythm.
His name was Evan Brooks.
He wanted to learn drums.
Nora helped him count eighth notes during lunch.
Claire began writing tiny melodies in a notebook. They were stiff and predictable at first. Nora never laughed.
Ben formed a trio with Sofia on cello and asked Nora to join on piano. They sounded terrible for three rehearsals and then suddenly, on the fourth, something clicked.
Luke came to that rehearsal straight from the hospital and sat in the back with his work boots still on.
Nora noticed him wiping his eyes.
Later, on the bus home, she asked why.
"Your mom always wanted the house full of kids making noise," he said. "I thought losing her meant that part was over."
Nora leaned against his arm.
"Maybe it's not over. Maybe it's just somewhere else."
The painted keyboard stayed on their kitchen table even after Nora gained regular access to real pianos.
Luke offered to throw it away once.
Nora looked horrified.
"No."
"It takes up half the table."
"Then we have half a table."
He laughed and left it there.
A year after the day Ms. Hargrove forced her to play, Hawthorne held another spring showcase.
This time Nora was not the final performer.
She asked not to be.
Mr. Alvarez built the program around ensembles, beginners, and original work. Claire performed a short piece she had composed herself. Evan played drums with a group of fourth graders. Ben and Sofia performed a duet that went slightly off tempo and recovered without panic.
Nora played near the middle.
She finally chose "Blue Window."
But before she began, she spoke into the microphone.
"My mom started this piece when she was sick. I finished it after she died. For a while I thought that meant it was only about her. Then I thought it was about me. Now I think it might be about both of us, and my dad too. Maybe music can belong to more than one person without anyone losing it."