The first thing twelve-year-old Nora Bell heard when she entered the recital studio was a woman laughing at her violin. It was not a surprised laugh, or the kind people offer when children do something charming. It was deliberate and bright, pitched to carry across a room where everyone had been speaking in careful, expensive voices. Nora had heard enough laughter directed at her clothes to recognize the difference. She stopped just inside the door, her left hand tightening around the cracked black handle of a case that had belonged to her grandfather.

"Oh, surely that isn't what she plans to play," the woman said. Her name was Vivienne Langford, and her family had donated enough money to the Bellweather Conservatory's new performance wing to have their name carved into its limestone entrance. She wore a cream jacket and a bracelet that flashed when she raised her hand toward Nora. "That instrument looks like it was rescued from a flooded basement. Are we holding a charity collection or auditions for serious musicians?"
There were twenty-four children in the room, most accompanied by parents. A few looked down at their shoes. Others stared openly at Nora's faded green sweater, the patched cuff on her coat, and the case whose latches had been replaced by two mismatched brass catches. A blonde girl seated near the front laughed because her mother had laughed. The girl was eleven, dressed in a pale blue sweater and black concert skirt, and her violin lay on her lap in a case lined with violet velvet. She was Vivienne's daughter, Clara. Nora knew that because she had studied the conservatory's website on the library computer until the photographs became familiar.
"My mother said it was all right for me to come," Nora answered. She tried to keep her voice steady. "I have an audition letter."
"An invitation to audition is not an invitation to embarrass yourself," Vivienne replied. "Someone ought to have explained that before you spent bus fare getting here." She looked toward the instructor's desk, where a woman in dark glasses was sorting scores. "Dr. Ellery, perhaps you can find this child a beginner's class. Or a replacement instrument. Preferably both."
Nora's cheeks burned. She wanted to say that the violin had a name, that its dark wood and worn edges were not evidence of neglect, that it had carried music through two generations of a family without money for portraits or marble buildings. Instead she held the case against her leg. Her mother had ironed that green sweater at five in the morning, after working a double shift at St. Agnes Hospital. Nora had promised not to cry if anyone was unkind. She had not expected to need that promise before taking the violin out.
Dr. Margaret Ellery looked up. She was fifty-three, compact and gray-haired, with the posture of someone who had spent thirty years listening for notes that were almost right. Her gaze moved from Vivienne to Nora, then down to the case. She did not laugh. "Miss Bell, you are early," she said. "We will hear you in the order listed. Please take a seat."
"I hope she has a tuner," Clara murmured. The boy beside her snickered. "That thing probably makes the sound of a screen door."