If any attorney officer or clerk in this room finds that standard unacceptable, I suggest you tender your resignation to the county clerk immediately. She let the statement settle. No one moved. No one breathed. "Very well," Naomi said.
She opened the folder. "Madam Clerk, call the first case." Brenda, the clerk, leaned into her microphone. Her hands were shaking slightly, but her voice was surprisingly strong. State of New York versus Michael Torres.
Docket number 44B902. A young man in the second row stood up nervously. His public defender grabbed a file and hurried toward the podium. The machine of courtroom 302 began to grind again, but the gears were turning differently now. For the first time in 15 years, they were turning toward justice.
Michael Torres stepped up to the wooden podium. He was 19, wearing a faded mechanic shirt with someone else's name stitched over the pocket. His hands gripped the edges of the podium so hard his knuckles bled white. Next to him stood Simon Clark, a public defender who looked like he hadn't slept since law school. Clark was already opening a manila folder, his eyes scanning a heavily redacted police report.
Your honor, Clark began, his voice carrying the hurried, exhausted cadence of a man who usually processed 10 cases an hour. My client is charged with misdemeanor possession. We have reviewed the state's offer in exchange for a guilty plea. Today, the state is offering 6 months of supervised probation and mandatory drug counseling with court fees to be assessed. It was the standard deal, the conveyor belt.
Sign the paper, pay the county a few hundred you don't have, get trapped in the probation system, and clear the docket. Stanton, seated at the prosecution table, didn't even look up. He just held a pen, ready to check a box on his sheet. Naomi didn't pick up her pen. She looked down at the file.
She looked at Michael Torres. "Mr. Clark," Naomi said quietly. "Have you actually read the probable cause affidavit?" Clark blinked, caught off guard. "Yes, your honor. The arresting officer states he observed a traffic infraction."
"Read it aloud, counselor," Naomi interrupted. "The specific paragraph detailing the initiation of the stop. Read it for the record." Clark cleared his throat, shuffling the papers. He found the paragraph.
Officer states he observed the defendant's vehicle traveling northbound on Fifth Avenue at approximately 45 miles per hour. Officer initiated a traffic stop after claiming to smell the distinct odor of unburnt marijuana emanating from the vehicle. Naomi looked over the bench at William Stanton. The prosecutor was suddenly sitting very still. "Mr. Stanton," Naomi said, her voice dripping with clinical skepticism. "Does the state stand by this affidavit?"
Stanton stood up. He buttoned his suit jacket. His hands were damp. Your honor, the officer is a sworn member of law enforcement. We rely on their field observations.
"You rely on a physical impossibility," Naomi shot back. The courtroom was dead silent. Every attorney was watching. The defendant was driving 45 mph. The windows of his vehicle, according to the impound report attached to your own file, were rolled up.