Some months the envelopes seemed to negotiate with one another, taking money from one obligation to meet another. Eli knew how to read the arrangement without opening them. He also knew his mother did not like him watching her face when bills arrived, so he learned to look busy with his schoolbooks until she had decided how to handle the next problem.
Renee had once imagined becoming a nurse. She had completed prerequisite courses at a community college before her father fell ill and Eli's father left their marriage during a period of strained finances. Later she told her son that her dreams had not died; they had simply been postponed so long they required new directions. She did not speak bitterly about his father, who sent occasional birthday cards and little else. She was too occupied with what the next day demanded. Eli sometimes wondered whether she believed the explanation she offered him, but he never doubted that she intended him to have more choices than she had possessed.
His first encounter with a piano occurred when he was six. Mrs. Lillian Price lived on the second floor of their building, three doors down from the stairwell, and had an upright whose walnut finish had faded around the edges. She had once taught beginners at a community music center, but arthritis made the longer lessons painful, and she had stopped accepting students. Eli helped her carry groceries in exchange for the occasional slice of pound cake. One afternoon he found her sitting beside the piano, sorting old sheet music into cardboard boxes. He asked why anyone would keep an instrument they did not play anymore.
"Because it remembers more than I do," she said, and then laughed at the solemn expression he gave her. She opened the keyboard cover and asked if he wanted to try one note. He pressed a key, listened until the sound disappeared, then pressed another. He liked that the notes remained distinct even after they began to overlap in his hearing. Mrs. Price showed him the difference between neighboring notes and a simple interval, but she did not make a lecture out of it. He sat there until Renee knocked on the door looking for him, and by then he had discovered that he could lose track of time without becoming afraid.
The next afternoon he returned. Then he returned again, bringing his homework so Mrs. Price could assure his mother that the music would not replace his responsibilities. She taught him finger numbers, basic reading, the shape of a phrase, and why a passage could be technically accurate without saying much. Her lessons were modest and irregular, interrupted by swelling in her hands and appointments she did not discuss. She gave him recordings of Debussy, Ravel and Chopin from a small collection of compact discs and told him that listening was work, too. By his ninth birthday he was playing hymns at the neighborhood church because the regular pianist had moved away, though he still required a patient adult to turn pages when the score grew complicated.