It's been a long time. 15 Years, " he said. " You were 12. I remember. " He looked at her for a moment. "
You look like your father, " he said. You always did. Something moved through Clara's face that she controlled immediately. Why are you here? Robert Whitmore sat back down slowly.
I heard about the case. A colleague in Helena mentioned it. Whitmore is not a common name, and when he described what was happening, I understood immediately who was involved. He folded his hands. I came because I wanted to see for myself that you were safe and because I wanted to tell you something that should have been said years ago.
What's that? Clara said, "Your father wrote to me, " Robert said, 6 months before he died. He told me about Gerald, about what he suspected Gerald was doing with the business accounts. He didn't have proof, but he suspected. He asked me to come back to help him look into it.
He looked at his hands. I didn't come. I had built a life in San Francisco, and coming back meant reopening everything that had happened between Thomas and me and I. He stopped. I told myself I'd come in the spring. I told myself there was time.
He looked up at Clara. He died in February. The sitting room was very quiet. Clara stood in the middle of it and Nathan could see her processing this the additional layer of it. The fact that her father had known or suspected and had reached out and Robert had waited too long and the chain of delayed actions that led to three years of fraud and nine families and a woman kneeling in the dark with a sack on her head.
He knew, Clara said, not a question. He suspected, Robert said. He wasn't certain, but yes, he never told me. He wouldn't have. He wanted to protect you from it.
Robert paused. I think he also hoped he was wrong. Clara was quiet for a moment. Nathan did not move. He stood near the door and let this be what it was.
Her space, her family, her reckoning with a story that kept revealing new dimensions every time she thought she knew its shape. You should have come, she said finally. Yes, Robert said. I should have if you had come when he asked. I know, Robert said.
I know what it might have prevented. I'm going to live with that. He held her gaze with the steadiness of a man who has decided not to look away from the thing he owes. I'm not here to ask you to absolve me of it. I'm here because you are Thomas's daughter and you did something extraordinary and I am the only Witmore left who can stand up and say so out loud.