Ladies and gentlemen, Ashford said, "I understand this woman has told you a story, and I have no doubt she believes it. But I'd ask you to consider she is alone. She is estranged from her family. She has been living in the home of a man she barely knows. She has every reason to construct a narrative that justifies those choices.
The lawyer beside him opened his case and produced a document. We have here a sworn statement from her uncle Gerald Witmore attesting to Miss Whitmore's instability since her father's death. Additionally, "Put that away, " Nathan said. His voice was not loud. It didn't need to be.
The lawyer stopped. Nathan stepped forward one step two until he was standing between the crowd and Ashford's horse. He looked up at Ashford and he said without raising his voice, "You rode into this town on a Sunday morning with a lawyer and a sworn statement. And the sworn statement is from the man you paid $40,000 to. You want these people to weigh that against a woman who walked through the dark with her hands tied and her face covered and still had the presence of mind to copy every page of evidence before she left.
Ashford looked at him, the calm, cold look of a man deciding how hard to push. Cole, he said, you've been named in a legal action. You'd be wise to step back. You've named me in a legal action, Nathan said, because I let a woman sleep in my spare room instead of sending her back to yours. I'll let a judge sort out which one of us that reflects poorly on.
A sound went through the crowd. Not quite laughter. Something sharper, something that had the shape of a point being made and landing. Ashford shifted in his saddle. The lawyer said something in a low voice, and Ashford's jaw tightened.
And then and Nathan would think about this moment for a long time afterward. And then Gerald Hatch stepped forward. Old Gerald Hatch, who had been the center of the gossip network, who had wondered aloud about Clara arriving in strange circumstances, who had looked uncomfortable every time Nathan saw him since. Gerald Hatch stepped forward and said, "Mr. Ashford, James Carver bought feed from my store for 12 years. He was a good man and a good customer.
And he lost his land two years ago. And nobody could explain how. You want to talk about sworn statements? Come back tomorrow and I'll have one of my own ready for your lawyer. Ashford looked at Gerald.
Gerald looked back. He was 63 years old, and he had been in this town for 40 of those years, and he was standing in front of the church where he had attended every Sunday since before Ashford had owned a single acre of Montana territory. Ashford looked at