Officer Threatens Arrest Over Music — Then the Booking Desk Went Silent

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Her voice was calm, educated, and icy. "The music," Miller said, stepping closer, invading her personal space. "Turn it off now. We got complaints. You're disturbing the peace."

Elena Ross looked at the small Bose speaker. Then she looked back at Officer Miller. "Officer Miller," she said, reading his tag again. "This is a public park. The city ordinance for noise in public spaces, specifically Section 14B, allows for amplified sound as long as it does not exceed 60 dB at a distance of 50 feet.

As you can hear, or perhaps fail to hear, this music is barely audible at 10 feet. I am not disturbing the peace." Miller blinked. He wasn't expecting a citation of the municipal code. He was expecting an apology or an argument he could shout down.

Intelligence in a suspect always made him defensive. It made him feel small, and Miller hated feeling small. "I don't care about the decibels," Miller snapped. "I have a complainant who says you're screaming at people and acting aggressive, and right now arguing with police is exactly the kind of attitude that gets you in trouble. So, I'm telling you again, turn the music off or I'm seizing the equipment."

Elena closed her book. She stood up. She was 5 feet 7 inches tall, but she carried herself with the posture of someone much taller. Officer, the complainant lied to you. I have been sitting here reading for two hours.

I haven't spoken to a soul. I have a permit for this pavilion. She gestured to a printed paper taped to the table, which grants me exclusive use of this space until 5:00 p.m. If you would like to see my identification and the permit, I am happy to provide them, but I will not be turning off my music because I am not violating any laws. Miller's face turned a shade of red that matched the stripes on the flag patch on his shoulder. This was it, the challenge.

She was saying no. "You think you're a lawyer or something?" Miller sneered. "I am a lawyer, actually," Elena said. "And I know that you are currently detaining me without reasonable suspicion of a crime.

A false noise complaint does not give you the authority to harass a citizen complying with the law." Miller took a step back and put his hand on his radio. "Okay, you want to play it that way? You're refusing a lawful order." "An unlawful order is not a lawful order just because a police officer says it," Elena corrected him.

And you haven't identified what crime I'm committing. "Disorderly conduct," Miller said, grasping for the catch-all charge officers used when their feelings were hurt. "Creating a public nuisance, and now failure to obey." "Failure to obey an order that has no legal standing is not a crime, Officer Miller." Elena reached for her purse.

I am going to show you my credentials. I suggest you look at them very carefully before you take another step. "Don't reach for anything!" Miller shouted, his hand dropping to his holster. The sudden escalation was jarring.

Families in the distance stopped playing, heads turned. "Put the bag down. Hands where I can see them." Elena froze. She knew the statistics.

News in the same category

Officer Threatens Arrest Over Music — Then the Booking Desk Went Silent

8 Part