Officer Derek Miller read the dispatch notes. Subject playing loud music, shouting at passersby, possible intoxication, complainant feels threatened. Miller felt a surge of adrenaline. This was what he liked, a tangible problem, a bad actor ruining a nice day. Miller had a reputation in the precinct and not the good kind.
His file was thick with counseling memos, the department's polite way of saying he had a temper. He had four formal complaints in the last two years. One for using profane language with a grandmother during a traffic stop, two for escalating verbal disputes into shoving matches, and one for an unlawful search of a vehicle that got thrown out of court. His sergeant had told him just last week, "Miller, you need to learn to talk to people. You're a hammer, and you think everything is a nail.
Dial it back." But Miller didn't believe in dialing it back. He believed in establishing control. In his mind, the streets were chaotic and he was the iron fist that brought order. When he saw the call was at Oak Haven Park, his bias kicked into overdrive.
"Oak Haven," he thought. That's a nice area. If someone is causing trouble there, they don't belong there. He didn't consider that the caller might be exaggerating. He didn't consider that gang music was a racially coded dog whistle from a biased civilian.
He accepted the narrative immediately. There is a dangerous person in the park and it is my job to neutralize the threat. Miller pulled his cruiser onto the grass, bypassing the parking lot entirely to drive right up to the pavilion path. He wanted to make an entrance. He wanted to shock the subject into submission.
He put the car in park, leaving the lights flashing, and stepped out. He adjusted his belt and checked that his body camera was on. He loved the camera. He thought it showed how tough he was, and marched toward Pavilion 4. The first thing he noticed was the quiet.
There was no shouting. There was no window-rattling bass. There was just the wind in the trees and the very faint melancholic sound of a saxophone. But Miller was already committed to the narrative. If it wasn't loud now, she must have turned it down when she saw the cop car.
That was proof of guilt. He saw Elena Ross. She hadn't moved. She hadn't even looked up from her book when he slammed his car door. This infuriated him.
To Derek Miller, a lack of immediate attention was a sign of disrespect. A suspect should be nervous. A suspect should be looking for an exit. Elena Ross was turning a page. Miller stomped onto the concrete slab of the pavilion, his shadow falling across her book.
Turn it off, he barked. No greeting. No "Good afternoon." Just a command. Elena paused.
She placed a bookmark in her book and slowly looked up. She lowered her sunglasses, revealing eyes that had stared down cartel bosses and serial killers. She looked at Miller's name plate, then at his face. She didn't reach for the speaker. "Excuse me," she said.