OFFICER SMASHED A BLACK WOMAN’S CAR WINDOW DURING A TRAFFIC STOP — THEN HIS SERGEANT PULLED UP

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

She wanted to return to the moment before she saw the baton.

She wanted ordinary traffic stops to feel ordinary again.

Instead, she hired an attorney.

Not because she had dreamed of suing the police department.

Because within forty-eight hours she began receiving calls.

Investigators.

Insurance.

Vehicle repair representatives.

Department officials.

Everybody wanted statements.

Everybody used careful language.

Naomi needed someone whose job was to understand that language.

Her attorney's name was Rachel Kim.

Forty-one.

Short.

Precise.

Almost aggressively organized.

At their first meeting, Rachel placed a legal pad on the table.

“I'm going to tell you something you may not like.”

Naomi nodded.

“This case doesn't need a dramatic secret identity.”

Naomi frowned.

“What?”

Rachel smiled slightly.

“Online, people are already asking who you are.”

“Why?”

“Because everybody expects the twist.”

Rachel counted on her fingers.

“Federal agent. Judge. Prosecutor. Mayor's daughter. Police chief's wife.”

Naomi actually laughed.

“I'm none of those.”

“I know.”

Rachel leaned back.

“And that's important.”

Naomi looked at her.

Rachel continued.

“You don't need to be important for that window to matter.”

The sentence stayed with Naomi.

Perhaps because it was the first thing anyone had said that felt exactly right.

She had seen stories before.

Someone treated terribly.

Then a reveal.

The victim was wealthy.

Powerful.

Connected.

Decorated.

Famous.

And suddenly everyone understood why the aggressor had made a terrible mistake.

But what if Naomi had worked at a grocery store?

What if the sedan belonged to her employer?

What if she lived in a cheap apartment instead of Fairmont?

What if nobody had arrived?

Would the window have mattered less?

No.

Rachel tapped the legal pad.

“So we keep this simple.”

Naomi nodded.

“He stopped you.”

“Yes.”

“You complied with the document request.”

“Yes.”

“You asked why you were being ordered out.”

“Yes.”

“You requested a supervisor.”

“Yes.”

“You called 911.”

“Yes.”

“He broke the window.”

“Yes.”

Rachel closed the pad.

“That's enough.”

Three weeks later, Naomi attended a formal interview at police headquarters.

Sergeant Mitchell was not in the room.

Neither was Cole.

Two internal investigators sat across from her.

Rachel sat beside her.

The investigators asked detailed questions.

Where were Naomi's hands?

Did she ever reach toward the glove compartment?

Had she cursed?

Did she threaten Cole?

Did she unlock the door?

Had Cole touched the handle before or after her 911 call?

Naomi answered everything.

Then one investigator asked:

“Why didn't you simply exit when instructed?”

Rachel shifted slightly.

Naomi answered before she could.

“Because I was afraid.”

The investigator waited.

Naomi continued.

“He was already angry before I understood why he'd stopped me.”

She folded her hands.

“When he tried the locked handle, I got more afraid.”

“Did you believe exiting would increase the danger?”

“I didn't know.”

“Then why request a supervisor?”

“Because I wanted another officer there.”

The investigator nodded.

Naomi looked directly at him.

“And I was right.”

He paused.

“How so?”

“When another officer arrived, Officer Cole stopped.”

Nobody spoke.

Naomi continued.

“The baton stopped.”

Rachel said nothing.

She didn't need to.

Cole's disciplinary hearing was not public.

The final department findings were.

The original lane-change allegation was not supported by available video.

Cole had failed to adequately explain the basis for escalating the stop.

His report omitted Naomi's repeated requests for a supervisor.

His description of her as “physically noncompliant” was inconsistent with all available footage before the window was broken.

The baton strike was determined to violate department use-of-force policy.

But one detail became the center of the review.

Cole claimed he feared Naomi might drive away.

His body camera showed the sedan in park.

News in the same category

OFFICER SMASHED A BLACK WOMAN’S CAR WINDOW DURING A TRAFFIC STOP — THEN HIS SERGEANT PULLED UP

8 Part