That evening she told him she was proud of how he had handled the question. He looked uncomfortable. 'I didn't do anything special.' Nora said, 'You decided what you were willing to talk about.' Elias considered it. 'I suppose I did.' They stood beside the trailer while the sky turned copper over the low hills. From the highway came the distant rumble of motorcycles traveling north. Elias listened without flinching. The sound meant ordinary people going somewhere now, not a roadblock or a locked room. Nora noticed and said nothing. Some victories belonged most fully to the person who experienced them.
Later that year, the diner hosted a small private supper for the people who had helped during the investigation. Walter limited the guest list because he could not bear another room filled with motorcycles and reporters. Elena came with Marjorie, who had stayed with Nora during the first frightening nights. Daniel brought his wife. Elise attended briefly after confirming there was no conflict with ongoing matters. Boone, Margaret, Jonah, and Russell arrived in ordinary clothes. Mr. Garrison claimed his place in the corner booth. Nora prepared a simple meal with June, and Walter insisted on making the peach pie himself. Nobody gave speeches. They exchanged stories about roads, work, classes, and the changing price of gasoline.
At the end of supper, Russell reached into his pocket and placed a silver lighter on the table. Nora stared. It was not Elias's. It was an inexpensive copy he had bought at a roadside shop, with a small crescent scratched onto one corner. Russell said he had made it himself because he wanted a reminder of the day Nora challenged him in front of forty riders. Walter laughed. 'You needed a lighter for that?' Russell replied, 'Apparently I need instructions in writing.' Nora picked it up and examined the crude scratch. 'You made the mark too big,' she said. Russell shrugged. 'I'm better with engines than delicate work.' Elias grinned. 'That's generous.' The table filled with laughter.
Then Elias took the original lighter from his pocket. He had carried it again for months, though he no longer smoked. He turned it over in his hand and showed the scratched corner to Russell. 'Mom used to call it the ugly moon,' he said. Nora nodded. She remembered their mother standing in the kitchen, laughing at the damage. Elias opened the lid and closed it. The familiar click crossed the table. Russell watched without speaking. Elias placed the lighter between himself and Nora. 'This was the first thing she recognized when she thought I'd never come home.' He looked at his sister. 'I'm glad you did.'
Nora touched the edge of the metal. 'I wasn't brave when I walked up to that table,' she said. 'I was afraid I was about to hear that you were dead.' Russell answered, 'You asked anyway.' Nora shook her head. 'I didn't know how not to.' She thought of the frightened