Somebody came at him from the right once and hurt him bad. And now he won't give a soul his blind side. You've been fighting him for months, haven't you? Caleb stopped walking. How'd you know that?
Because you called him mean, and men call a horse mean when the horses beat them. She climbed down off the rail slow on the left side, keeping herself in the ran's good eye the whole way. My father used to say, "There's no such thing as a bad horse. Only a horse that's asking a question nobody bothered to answer. " She held out her hand, palm down low, and she waited, and she did not move toward the animal at all. She just stood there and let him decide.
What's his name? Doesn't have one. I don't name what I can't ride. That's your whole trouble right there, Clara murmured. And she wasn't talking to Caleb anymore.
She'd gone soft and low, all her attention on the own. Nobody named you, did they? Nobody named you, and nobody answered your question, and everybody called you mean, the horse's ears came forward. His off eye rolled, showing white. And then slowly slowly he turned his head and for the first time in the 8 months Caleb had owned him, that horse gave a human being his blind side on purpose.
Caleb watched his own untameable horse lower its head into a strange woman's hand, and he felt something turn over in his chest that he did not have a name for and did not want one. "Well," he said when he could, "I'll be damned probably. " Clara agreed, not looking at him. Both hands on the own now. And there was the first real smile he'd seen on her small and private aimed entirely at a horse. But not today.
Today you've got a horse you can ride, and I've earned my breakfast, so we're both ahead. He named the ran that evening. He called him Elias. He didn't tell Clara why, and he didn't have to. And when she heard him say it low to the horse at the fence, "Easy, Elias, easy. " Now she went still at the cabin door with the wash water in her hands and stood there a long moment before she went inside.
And she didn't say a word about it either. That was how it went those first two weeks. Not with words, with small things laid down carefully one at a time, like stones set in a creek so a person can cross without getting swept off. He gave her the ran's trust, and she gave him back a horse worth four times what he'd have sold it for. She found the books he'd been keeping, which were not books at all, just a cigar box of receipts and a great deal of hoping, and she spread them out on the table one night without asking, and worked at them by lamplight for 3 hours.
And when she was done, she looked up at him with a face gone flat with a kind of professional outrage, and said, "Mr. Whitaker, the man you buy your winter feed from, has been robbing you for years, cheerfully to your face. Did you know that? I figured his prices were high. His prices are theft.
I've seen his numbers against three other suppliers I know of down south, and he's charging you near double. And I'd bet my mother's dress he does it because you're the man who comes to town once a year and never argues and never checks. You're easy money to him. You've been easy money to that whole town for 11 years. She stabbed a finger at the receipts.
Not anymore. I'll write the letters myself. You'll write letters. I'll write letters. She said it like a woman declaring a war.
You just have to sign them. And what's that going to save me? Clara did some figuring, her lips moving her pencil scratching. Then she turned the paper around and pushed it across the table. And Caleb looked at the number at the bottom.
And then he looked at it again. That can't be right. It's right. In a year, every year, Clara said. Every year since you built this place, that number's been walking out of your pocket and into that man's.
And you never felt it because you never counted it. That's what I do, Mr. Whitaker. That's the thing my father taught me that I'm actually good at. Anybody can add.
I can find. She sat back and there was color in her face now. The first real color he'd seen since she'd walked up his trace, half dead. And Caleb understood he was looking at a person who had just for the first time in three weeks remembered that she was good at something. I told you I'd be a bargain, she said quieter.
I meant it. I don't want to be somebody you rescued. I've got no use for that. You're not, Caleb said and found he meant it. I've got a hand who can gentle a horse nobody could touch and catch a thief I've been feeding for a decade.
That's not rescuing. That's the best hire I ever made. He tapped the number on the paper. Write your letters. I'll sign whatever you put in front of me.
She smiled at that quick and pleased and looked back down at the receipts. And Caleb sat across the table from her in the lamplight and thought with a small cold shock like stepping into creek water that he had not sat across a lamp lit table from another living person in 11 years, and that he had somehow forgotten it was a thing a man could miss. He put the thought away. He'd made a rule, a cold offer. He'd told her a business.
He wasn't going to be the fool who wrote a rule down one morning and started breaking it by the second week. He got up and banked the fire and said good night. And he went to the leanto. He'd started building against the cabin's north wall because he'd meant what he said about her having her own room. And he wasn't a man to say a thing and not do it.
And he lay out there on a cot under a half-finished roof and listened to the small sounds of another person moving in his house. And he did not sleep for a long while and he told himself it was because the roof wasn't finished and the night was cold. The first sign that the mountain had stopped being far enough came 11 days after the wedding. Caleb had ridden down to Hollow Creek for salt and nails alone because he still didn't like the idea of Clara in that town. And he was loading the wagon outside the merkantile when the storekeeper, a fat, cautious man named Puit, who'd never given Caleb more than the weather in 11 years, leaned across a barrel of nails and said low, not looking at him.
Fella was in here day before yesterday asking after you. Caleb kept loading. Fellas ask after me all the time. I'm a fascinating man. Not funny.
Whitaker. Puit wiped his hands on his apron, still not meeting Caleb's eye. And Caleb understood the man was scared. And Puit didn't scare easy. And that was its own kind of information.
This one wasn't from around here. City clothes, good boots, the soft-handed kind that don't work but always got money. He glanced up quick then away. Asked, "Did I know a Caleb Whitaker? " asked, "Was it true you'd got married recent? " Asked, "Did anybody know where the woman came from? " Caleb's hands went still on the sack of salt. What'd you tell him?