“My Father Said You Needed a Wife,” She Whispered — The Mountain Cowboy Tried to Shut the Door

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Cool and clear from up on the horse and not one tremor in it. And Caleb thought, "There, there's the horse trainer. There's the bookkeeper. There's the woman who walked 40 miles. " He swung back up in front of her and clicked the horse forward, and they rode the rest of the way to the preacher's door through a silence that had entirely changed its flavor. "You didn't have to do that," Clara said quietly behind him.

"Yes, I did. He'll hate you for it now. He hated me before. Now he'll just be quieter about it. Caleb rained up at the preacher's gate.

That's the most a man can hope for in a place like this. Not to be loved, just to be too much trouble to bother. The preacher was an old man named Anel Cobb, and he'd married and buried half of Hollow Creek in his time, and he'd stopped being surprised by anything the human race got up to somewhere around the second decade of it. He looked at Caleb and he looked at Clara and he did not ask a single one of the questions that a younger man might have asked. You're of age the both of you marrying free.

No other man or woman got a lawful claim on either. Yes, Caleb said. Yes, said Clara. Then I don't need to know the rest and I expect you'd rather I didn't. Cobb reached for his book.

I've married folks for love and I've married folks for land and I've married folks for reasons they took to their graves without telling me. And do you know what I've learned in 50 years of it? Neither of them answered that it don't much matter why two people stand up in front of God. The old man said opening the book. It matters what they do the morning after.

Love that starts hot burns out. I've buried the marriages to prove it. But a marriage that starts as a promise kept. He looked up at Caleb over his spectacles, and there was something almost gentle in it. That's a fire that can catch slow.

I've buried fewer of those. He found his place. Take her hand, son. You can't make a promise to a woman standing 3 ft off from her. Caleb hesitated.

Then he reached back and Clara put her hand in his, and her fingers were cold and steady, and his were steady, too. And the old preacher began to read the words that would build Clara Bennett her wall. And Caleb Whitaker, standing in a dim front room with a stranger's cold hand in his, and a dead man's promise finally coming due, found that he could not quite look at her while the words were said, because if he looked at her, he was afraid of what his own face might do. And he had sworn 11 years ago that his face would never do that again. He kept his eyes on the preacher.

He said, "I do. " to the ceiling. And 40 mi to the south in a valley where the biggest house threw the longest shadow. A rider was already saddling a fast horse because a man named Victor Harrington had spent 3 weeks looking for a woman who'd told him no. And that very morning, a talkative fellow passing through from a town called Hollow Creek had mentioned over a beer he hadn't paid for that the strangest thing had happened up north. Caleb Whitaker had come down out of his mountain, and Caleb Whitaker had gone and got himself married.

They rode back up the mountain, married, and neither of them said a word about it for the first hour. It was Clara who broke it and she broke it the way she seemed to break most silences sideways from an angle Caleb didn't see coming. You said I do to the ceiling, she said. Caleb kept his eyes on the trace ahead. Did I?

You did the whole time. I had a fine view of the side of your face and you never once looked at me. You looked at that water stain on Preacher Cobb's ceiling like it owed you money. I was concentrating on the ceiling, on not making a mistake. Behind him, he felt rather than heard the small breath she let out.

Not quite a laugh. Well, she said, I've been married a whole 2 hours now, and my husband has never looked me in the eye. My mother would have a great deal to say about that. Your mother's not here. No.

Clara agreed, and the lightness went out of it. No, she's not. Caleb regretted it the moment it was out of his mouth and he was a man who did not often regret his words because he did not often waste any. He wrote on for a minute chewing on it and then he said gruff that came out harder than I meant it. It's all right.

It's not. You lost your father 3 weeks ago and I threw your dead mother at you to win a conversation I wasn't even losing. He shook his head. That was small of me. Clara was quiet a moment.

You always do that. Do what? Take a thing back. Most men, they say the hard thing and then they just let it sit there and go rotten because taking it back would cost them something. You gave it right back.

Not even a full minute later. My wife's been dead 11 years, Caleb said, and he didn't know why he said it, except that the mountain was wide and quiet, and she was the first person he'd talked to for more than a passing minute in longer than he could recall. You want to know a thing about grief nobody tells you? It's the small unkind things that keep you up at night. Not the big ones.

The big ones you can forgive yourself because you were out of your mind. It's the small ones. The little cruelties you had time to think about and did anyway. Those are the ones that come back. He clicked to the horse.

I've got enough of those. I'm not adding to the pile with you. Clara didn't answer that. But when they'd written another h 100red yard, she said quietly, "Thank you. " And Caleb understood she wasn't thanking him for taking it back. She was thanking him for the marriage, for the whole of it, for a thing too big to name out loud.

And she'd found a small doorway to say it through. Don't thank me. Caleb said, "You haven't seen the work yet. " The work was the making of them in the end, though neither of them could have known it that first week. Caleb had thought in the thin gray hours of the night he'd lain awake making his decision that the hard part would be the living together. Two strangers in a small cabin.

He'd braced for the awkwardness of it, for the thousand small collisions of two lives that had never learned to share a doorway. He'd built her a wall out of his own name, and he'd expected to spend the rest of his life on the cold side of it, polite and distant. Two people passing coffee across a table until they were old. What he had not braced for was that Clara Bennett could actually work. He found it out the second morning when he went to the paddic at first light and found her already there up on the top rail watching his big ran geling, the one nobody could get a saddle on the one he'd half decided to sell for what he could get because a horse a man can't ride is just an expensive way to feed flies.

Get down off there, he said. That one's mean. He's not mean. Clara didn't move. He's scared.

There's a difference and it matters a great deal to the horse. She tilted her head. Somebody heard him right side. Watch how he won't turn his off eye toward you. He keeps you on his left the whole time.

News in the same category

“My Father Said You Needed a Wife,” She Whispered — The Mountain Cowboy Tried to Shut the Door

20 Part