A square black stone.
The sheriff leaned back slowly.
"That's company manager Reuben Vale's ring."
Caleb looked at him. "You sure?"
"He wears it every day."
The case was no longer about three thieves in the mountains. It reached into Dry Creek itself.
Turner locked the whistle in his safe and sent a deputy toward the territorial marshal's office that evening. Caleb wanted Nora to stay in town, where there were more people and lawmen. Nora refused in writing. HOME IS CABIN.
Caleb smiled faintly. "All right. Home it is."
They returned under a sky filling with early snow.
For four days, nothing happened.
Caleb repaired the north fence. Nora canned the last apples. Neither said what they were both thinking. Danger had moved closer, and with it came a tenderness neither knew how to name. Caleb found himself watching for Nora whenever she left the room. Nora began touching his sleeve lightly when passing him, small contacts that carried more trust than any embrace.
One evening she placed a note beside his plate.
YOU ASK BEFORE TOUCHING ME.
Caleb read it. "Of course."
She shook her head and wrote again.
NO ONE DID BEFORE.
He did not know what to say.
So he wrote: THEY SHOULD HAVE.
Nora folded the paper and kept it.
The attack came during the first real snowstorm.
Caleb heard glass break at the back of the cabin. He was on his feet before the lamp hit the floor. A burning bottle rolled across the boards, spilling flame toward the wall. Nora grabbed a wool blanket and smothered it while Caleb fired one warning shot through the open window frame.
A bullet answered from outside.
Caleb pushed Nora down as wood splintered above the table.
"Cellar!"
This time she obeyed, but only after grabbing the small tin box containing her papers and the charcoal notes she had made for the sheriff.
Caleb moved to the porch side and saw Silas crossing the yard with two men. The storm made everything white and chaotic. One man went toward the barn. Caleb fired at the ground near his boots, forcing him behind a trough.
Then someone struck Caleb from the side.
He had not seen the fourth man enter through the back.
The blow dropped him to one knee. He turned, caught the attacker's wrist, and drove him into the wall. They struggled across the floor, knocking over a chair. Caleb felt a knife scrape his ribs before he got leverage and threw the man toward the fireplace.
Silas burst through the front door.
"Where is she?"
Caleb reached for his rifle, but Silas kicked it away.
The second blow caught Caleb in the shoulder. The third drove him backward into the table. He heard Nora's footsteps coming up from the cellar.