That night neither slept. They sat at the table with the broken whistle between them and decided what came next. Caleb argued they should go to Sheriff Elias Turner in Dry Creek. Nora wrote that Silas had friends everywhere. Caleb asked whether Turner was one of them. Nora wrote: DON'T KNOW.
"Then we'll find out," Caleb said.
She stared at him.
He leaned forward. "But not because I'm deciding for you. Do you want to go?"
Nora looked at the whistle. Then she wrote one word.
YES.
They left at first light.
Dry Creek was busier than usual because a freight wagon had arrived from Denver. Caleb kept Nora close but not hidden. He wanted Silas's men to know she was no longer isolated, but he did not want her to feel guarded like property. They had nearly reached the sheriff's office when a shot cracked from the far side of the street.
Caleb grabbed Nora by the shoulders and pulled her behind a water trough as a bullet punched into the hitching post where she had been standing.
Horses screamed. People scattered.
A second rider fired from an alley.
Caleb drew and returned one shot, deliberately high enough to force the man back without risking the crowd. Nora crouched behind the trough, breathing hard. She saw another attacker moving behind Caleb and struck the side of the trough with her palm, pointing sharply.
Caleb turned in time.
The third man hesitated when he saw the sheriff emerge from his office with a shotgun.
"Drop it!" Turner shouted.
The attacker fled instead. The other two followed.
Sheriff Turner rushed across the street. He was sixty, broad-bellied, gray-mustached, and far quicker than he looked.
"Mercer, what in God's name?"
Caleb helped Nora stand. "We need to talk somewhere without windows."
Inside the sheriff's office, Nora placed the broken whistle on Turner's desk.
The sheriff's expression changed immediately.
"Where'd you get this?"
Nora looked to Caleb.
"It was taken from a stage guard killed south of Hollow Bridge," Caleb said. "She saw it happen."
Turner looked at Nora carefully. "Can she testify?"
Caleb's eyes hardened. "She can communicate. That's enough to start listening."
To Turner's credit, he apologized.
They spent three hours building the story. Nora wrote names. Drew the bridge. Marked a dry wash where the stolen gold had been transferred. She remembered details no one else would have noticed: one horse with a white left foreleg, a torn red saddle blanket, a brass buckle shaped like a crescent. Turner pulled old reports and discovered references matching each detail.
By late afternoon, one fact had become clear.
Silas Crowe had not been stealing alone.
Someone inside the stage company had altered schedules and shipment lists so his men knew exactly which wagons carried gold. The crushed whistle belonged to a guard named Benjamin Holt, whose body had been found months earlier with the claim that outlaws had taken everything. But Nora remembered seeing a fourth man remove papers from Holt's coat after the robbery.
Turner asked, "Do you remember his face?"
Nora shook her head.
Then she paused and drew something: a ring.