That evening Silas Venn appeared at the cabin with a white handkerchief tied to his rifle. He called from beyond the gate, saying he wanted to talk. Nathaniel stepped onto the porch while Eliza waited inside with her shotgun. Venn was a hard-looking man with a pale scar down his cheek and eyes that never rested in one place. “Pike offers you twice what you paid,” he said. “Take the money and go back to Kansas.”
Nathaniel leaned against a porch post. “And the widow?” Venn shrugged. “She signs and moves on. She’s young enough to find another husband.” Eliza stepped into view. “I buried mine because men like you were paid to make him disappear.” Venn’s gaze moved to her, then to the shotgun. “Careful, ma’am. You’re confusing rumor with proof.” Nathaniel answered, “We’ve found the proof.”
For the first time Venn looked unsettled. He recovered quickly and smiled. “Then you’d better sleep with your boots on.” He rode away before Nathaniel could reply. Eliza watched the road until dust swallowed him. “You shouldn't have told him,” she said. Nathaniel shook his head. “I wanted him to know he couldn't buy us.” She turned toward him. “Pride can get people killed just as surely as greed.”
They argued for the first time that night. Nathaniel believed they should fortify the cabin and wait for Warren. Eliza wanted to move the witnesses to the church and draw the attackers away from the graves. He accused her of taking unnecessary risks, and she accused him of deciding what was best because he had money and men. When she finally fell silent, he recognized the mistake in his own voice.
“I’m sorry,” he said. Eliza stood by the window, arms crossed. “I know you mean to help. But I fought this battle before you arrived, and I will have a say in how it ends.” Nathaniel nodded. “You will have more than a say. You lead, and I’ll stand beside you.” She looked at him for a long moment. “That is the first sensible thing you’ve said all evening.”
They agreed to move Miriam, Tomas, and Clara to the church at dawn while Nathaniel and two former trail hands guarded the homestead. His friends, Owen Pikeley and Gabriel Reyes, arrived that night from Abilene. Owen was a broad-shouldered former cavalry scout with a laugh that could shake windows. Gabriel was a quiet vaquero who knew every wash and dry creek bed within fifty miles. Both had ridden with Nathaniel long enough to understand that his silence meant trouble.
The next morning the church bell rang at an hour when no service was scheduled. Clara had arrived safely, but the stage driver carrying the first evidence packet had been found beaten beside the road. The packet was gone. Nathaniel feared the worst until a messenger from Fort Worth reported that Warren’s clerk had received the second packet intact. One set of originals was enough to begin legal proceedings, but not enough to protect the witnesses from men who had already murdered to preserve the fraud.