Nathaniel sent a rider to Fort Worth with a copy of the map and a message to an attorney he trusted, Judge Elias Warren, retired from the district bench. He did not ask for an army. He asked for a lawful way to preserve evidence before Pike could destroy it. Warren’s reply arrived two days later: Find the clerk. Keep witnesses alive. I am coming with a court officer and a reporter.
The reporter was Nathaniel’s idea of insurance. A sheriff could lose a document, but a story printed in a newspaper might outlive the man who tried to bury it. Eliza worried that publicity would make her a target. “I’m already a target,” she corrected herself. “I suppose the difference is whether anyone sees the shot.” Nathaniel promised he would not put her name into print without asking first.
The search for Clara Mayfield took them to a boardinghouse twenty miles south. Clara was twenty-nine, sharp-eyed, and frightened enough to keep a pistol beneath her pillow. She initially denied knowing Daniel. Then Nathaniel showed her the handwriting on the tracing paper. Clara sat down so suddenly that the bed frame creaked. “He came to the station with blood on his coat,” she said. “I told him to run. I thought I’d never see his name again.”
Clara admitted that her father, a deputy county clerk, had copied the original land entries after discovering alterations in the courthouse books. He stored the copies in a locked cabinet at the station, intending to send them to Austin. Pike found out, and Clara’s father died in a suspicious stable fire. Clara removed the papers before anyone could seize them. “I didn't take them to Denver,” she said. “I hid them where nobody would think to look.”
She led them to a neglected church outside town. Beneath a loose board in the choir loft lay a waxed canvas bundle containing deeds, affidavits, survey measurements, and payment records. One document bore the signature of a railroad representative who had agreed to purchase the creek corridor once the land was consolidated. Another listed payments to Sheriff Rusk and a hired gunman named Silas Venn. Nathaniel recognized Venn as the scarred man in the saloon.
Clara wanted to burn the papers rather than carry them back. “They killed my father,” she said. “They killed Daniel. They will kill you.” Eliza put a hand over hers. “They have spent years teaching us that truth is something we should be ashamed to hold. I am tired of learning that lesson.” Clara looked at the widow, then at the old ink on the papers. At last she agreed to testify.
They split the evidence into three packets. One went with a trusted stage driver toward Austin. One traveled with Nathaniel’s lawyer. The third remained with Clara and Eliza, who returned by different roads to avoid drawing attention. Nathaniel rode behind them until he was sure no one followed, but near Dry Willow Creek he found a fresh horseshoe print beside a stand of mesquite. It had a missing nail at the heel, the same mark he had seen outside the saloon.