She said, "The remaining documentation stands without those pages. The case against Vale is actually more straightforward without them. I told myself that several times while I was holding the bundle, she looked at the river. I wanted to protect him. He's my father and he's lying in a back room with a crushed leg and he did a terrible thing and then spent years trying to undo it and I wanted to protect him from the last consequence of it.
But you didn't, Caleb said. No, she looked down at the water moving past the bank. I didn't because I couldn't write in my ledger that we were bringing a full and honest account to the commission and know that I'd made it less than full. I couldn't do that and then stand in front of Robert Brennan and Daniel Marsh and ask them to trust what I was handing them. Caleb was quiet for a moment.
You could have just not told me. I know. Why did you? She thought about that. The river went on doing what rivers do because you didn't tell me about Ellis Burke until it was already in the room between us.
And I've been thinking since then about what it costs to carry something like that alone. She paused. I don't want to carry this one alone. He didn't say anything immediately. That was all right.
She hadn't told him because she needed him to say something. She'd told him because it was true and she was tired of the weight of it and he was the person she trusted with the weight. He said, "Then don't decide what kind of man he was." She looked at him. Samuel spent years building the evidence that would expose what he did.
Caleb said he put those papers where you'd find them. He knew what submitting the full account would cost the farm. He looked back at the river. He already made his decision about what kind of man he wanted to be. At the end, "You can't take that from him by protecting him, and you can't give it to him by throwing him to the fire."
He paused. Decide what kind of woman you're going to be. That's the only decision that's actually yours. She stood with that for a while. It was the clearest thing anyone had said to her in 4 days.
And it wasn't comfort exactly. It was harder than comfort. But it landed differently than comfort would have. It put the question back in her hands in a way that felt honest. Is that what you did?
She said with Burke. Did you decide what kind of man you were going to be? He was quiet long enough that she thought she'd gone too far, pushed into territory he'd offered her once and wasn't offering again. Then he said, "Sit down a minute." They sat on the bank above the waterline, the wet grass cold through their coats.
He took his hat off and held it in his hands. "I told you he died," Caleb said. I told you I made the choice to keep moving and he died. He looked at the hat. What I didn't say was that I went to Selena afterward to the county plot where they buried him.