They'd put over the grain sacks against the coming rain. He had his back to her, and she could tell from the way he was moving that he was tired. The deliberate care of someone whose muscles were making the work harder than it should be, but who wasn't going to stop until it was done. I need to show you something, she said. He turned.
She held out the papers. They sat on the far side of the limestone outcropping where the wind was cut and the lantern light held steady, and she watched him read. He read the way he did most things without hurrying, without skipping ahead. He turned pages in order and didn't ask questions until he'd reached the end. Then he set the papers down on his knee and was quiet for a moment.
The Board of Railroad Commissioners, he said, established this year. Samuel knew about it. That changes the mission. Yes, she had been working through this since she'd first read it. Building the new shape of what they were doing.
Getting the wheat to Red Fork and sold is still necessary. The farmers need that money. But if we arrive with grain and a successful sale and nothing else, Vale contests the weights, hires lawyers, and wears everyone down over two years while the fraudulent settlements stand. The commission has authority to compel records and impose real findings, but they need farmers willing to sign formal complaints together, not individually. How many farmers?
Enough that it can't be dismissed as a personal dispute. She looked at the papers. Samuel's documentation covers 8 years and names over 40 farms. If we can get the surviving farmers in this convoy to sign a joint complaint and add the documentation, it becomes a commission matter, not a county dispute. Caleb looked at the papers for another moment.
The documentation that proves all this also proves what Samuel did. Yes, you know what happens when you hand that over. The farm has to answer for what it benefited from, she said. We'll likely have to sell land, give back money that shouldn't have been ours. She said it plainly, the way you state an arithmetic fact.
That's what the evidence requires. He was quiet. There's a part of this I haven't decided yet, she said. The pages about Samuel's involvement. I could remove them from the documentation before we submit it.
The case against Vale stands without them. It's actually stronger in some ways because there's no argument that the complaint is coming from someone with personal liability. She looked at the papers, but Vale's defense will be that everyone who dealt with him did so willingly, and the complaint is motivated by self-interest. Samuel's pages destroy that defense. They prove that even someone who benefited from the arrangement knew it was wrong.
Caleb said nothing for a moment. He looked at the limestone rock face above them, pale and stre in the lantern light. So removing those pages makes the case legally cleaner, he said. Yes, but it changes what the case actually is. Yes.