For years, they had. The Whitakers next door kept an immaculate flower bed and occasionally gave away too many tomatoes. Across the street, Mrs. Ruiz walked a little white dog named Biscuit each evening. On summer Saturdays, children played basketball at the cul-de-sac, and if a ball rolled into somebody's yard, they retrieved it after asking. There were occasional noise complaints, misplaced trash bins, and the sort of small disagreements that come with living close together. We settled them by talking. Helen used to say a good neighborhood was not one without annoyances. It was one where people remembered the other person had a life before they opened their mouth.
Then Denise Maddox and her son moved into the rental two doors down. Denise was in her late forties and worked in an administrative office downtown. She was pleasant at first, bringing store-bought cookies to a neighborhood potluck and saying Connor was taking some time to find his direction after a training program had not worked out. I met Connor when his BMW was parked across part of my sidewalk. He moved it after I asked, though he did not apologize. His mother's expression, when she heard about the exchange later, was a small, tight smile that I mistook for embarrassment. I would learn that she had a habit of smiling in the moments when another person expected an answer.
Connor's trouble was not that he loved machines. I had worked with apprentices who could talk about engines for hours, and most of them grew into dependable adults. His BMW had considerable work done to it, much of it beyond anything the factory had planned, and his dirt bike wore fresh tires even when the rest of his equipment looked neglected. I could have found common ground with him easily. I offered once to show him how to check an uneven wear pattern that suggested a suspension issue. He laughed and said older mechanics always thought they knew better than computers. I told him computers were useful and tires were still honest. He walked away before we could discuss the difference.
The first real argument happened on a Tuesday afternoon. I was returning from the pharmacy when I found the BMW angled across the lower part of my driveway. Connor was unloading his dirt bike from a small trailer in the street. His car had been placed so that the rear wheel and most of the rear bumper were over my concrete apron, with the nose extending beyond the sidewalk. I waited for him to notice. When he did not, I rolled down the window and asked whether he could move it so I could get through. He looked at the open space beside my house and said I had a huge driveway. I answered that the size of it did not change who needed to use it.