I had not even given her permission to enter the driveway for that purpose. Then I explained the earlier parking disputes and provided the written incident timeline.
The company that insured Merritt Recovery sent its own investigator. He met me at the house, photographed the driveway and measured the distance between the sidewalk and the garage. He asked whether the Porsche might have obstructed a public right-of-way. I pointed to the survey pins and the property documents I had kept from when Helen and I bought the house. He measured anyway. I watched him pace the apron and take pictures from the street. He was not unfriendly, but he seemed disappointed that the measurements were straightforward. When he left, I called Caroline and asked whether every case had to become a conversation about whether the injured person was somehow responsible. She reminded me that insurers examined liability from every direction, including unpromising ones. I told her I understood that in theory and disliked it in practice.
The investigator's questions led to a curious development. Denise had sent the towing carrier a typed statement claiming that my Porsche was routinely parked where it blocked the sidewalk and that Connor had acted to clear a hazard after neighbors complained. The statement did not say she owned the property. It did not say she had obtained my permission. It merely created a picture of a vehicle so badly parked that somebody might have felt compelled to remove it. Brooke forwarded the relevant portion to me and asked for any measurements or imagery I had. I provided photographs from previous weeks and the driveway camera recording from the hour before the truck arrived. The car had been parked well inside the line. The street and sidewalk were unobstructed.
I was angry enough to telephone Denise. I even looked up her number before stopping myself. There was nothing to gain by asking her why she had written something the recordings could disprove. The matter had moved beyond what could be solved by a conversation on the porch. I told Allison, the prosecutor's investigator, about the statement, and she said she would request a copy through the appropriate channels if it became relevant to the criminal matter. Then I turned my attention back to the repair. It was becoming clear that Connor's actions had created a second problem: people who loved him, or depended on him, were trying to make his decisions sound less deliberate than they had been.
One morning I found a hand-delivered letter in my mailbox. It was unsigned, printed on ordinary paper, and said my Porsche had been an eyesore for years. It suggested that a reasonable neighbor would have accepted the offer of payment and allowed a young man to get his life back.