Patricia did not respond that way. Outside the courthouse, she told a local camera crew she had been punished for defending her faith. The clip circulated, and more clients canceled appointments with her event-planning firm. A few former customers publicly said they could not entrust weddings or family gatherings to someone who had made such exclusionary remarks. Others defended her right to believe what she wished. The debate became noisy, and I refused requests to appear on programs that wanted me to argue with strangers about whether Black people could be Christian. I had nothing to gain from making my faith a game for an audience.
Hannah and I spoke often about what responsibility we carried for Patricia's losses. She had owned her business for twenty years, and several employees had depended on its contracts. Yet we had not asked her clients to leave or organized a campaign against her. Her statements and public conduct were her own. We could feel sorrow for the consequences without accepting blame for causing her choices. Hannah said this was a distinction she often explained to students who had been taught to take responsibility for everyone else's emotions. I listened carefully, because even after all those months I still found myself wondering whether any kinder response from me might have prevented the conflict.
One evening, Anthony Pierce reminded me that people who are targeted by harassment are often asked to prove their goodness by tolerating more than anyone else would tolerate. "Don't confuse your vocation with an obligation to be helpless," he said. We were sitting in the empty sanctuary after a board meeting, watching the last light turn the stained-glass river dark. He spoke quietly about the many pastors before us who had organized food drives, opened schools, marched for fair treatment, and also gone to court when necessary. Their faith had not consisted only of enduring wrongs. It had also consisted of protecting neighbors from them.
Patricia's business eventually closed after a difficult season. I heard through neighborhood conversations that she had sold equipment, canceled a lease, and sought work outside event planning. Some neighbors spoke of the closure with satisfaction; others worried about her isolation. I did not join either conversation. Her business was no longer something I could change, and I had spent enough months looking across the street. When Diana Mercer asked whether we planned to move after the court decisions, Hannah answered before I could. "No," she said. "We bought this house because we wanted to live here. We still do."