The woman in my driveway pointed at the white strip of cloth beneath my chin and told me to take it off. For a second I thought I had misunderstood her. It was a beautiful Sunday afternoon in the Virginia suburbs, the kind that made people leave their windows open and their lawn chairs beneath the maples. I had just come home from church to collect a folder I had forgotten on the dining room table. My Bible was tucked beneath one arm, and my car keys were in my right hand.
"Take that collar off," she repeated. "You're making a mockery of Christianity."

Her name was Patricia Wexler. She was fifty-eight, lived across the street behind a wall of meticulously clipped hedges, and liked to remind people that she had helped establish the neighborhood's social committee. That afternoon she wore a cream designer tracksuit and sunglasses pushed into her blond hair. Her phone was already in her hand. I had learned during the previous eight months that Patricia often raised her voice when an audience was available, but I had not expected the sentence she said next.
"Jesus belongs to white people," she told me. "Your kind aren't accepted."
My name is Reverend Caleb Walker. I am forty-two years old, a Black husband, a father, and the senior pastor of New Hope Community Church. I had spent nearly two decades helping families bury loved ones, reconcile after bitter arguments, find work, and sometimes find enough food to reach the end of a difficult week. I had stood beside beds in emergency rooms and spoken at weddings where the bride and groom could hardly stop laughing. Yet there I was, facing a woman who believed she had the authority to tell me I could not wear the clothing of my calling outside my own house.
"Patricia," I said, "you are standing in my driveway. I need to get back to church."
She lifted her phone and began speaking into it. "Yes, dispatcher, I need an officer here immediately. There is a man impersonating a Christian minister in my neighborhood."
That was the instant I understood she had called 911. I put my Bible inside the SUV so that my hands would be free and visible. I did not know whether a police officer might misunderstand her description when the cruisers arrived, and I was not prepared to make any movement that could be mistaken for aggression. Patricia continued talking, emphasizing my race and the collar around my neck as though those were details from a criminal report. Across the street, a sprinkler clicked steadily through the grass. A boy on a bicycle stopped to stare until his mother called him home.
I wish I could say I felt only righteous anger. In truth I felt a mixture of disbelief, fatigue, and a fear I had learned to carry quietly. It was not the first time someone had doubted whether I belonged in a respectable neighborhood. It was the first time a neighbor had summoned police because she disliked the color of my skin and the cross I wore. I looked toward the security camera above our garage. Its small indicator was glowing. Whatever happened next, at least there would be a record of it.