That Saturday was warm and clear, the kind of late-May day Ohio gives you just before summer settles in for good. We started the party at four in the afternoon, not the ungodly early hour a garbled transcript would later suggest, because the older relatives liked to eat before dusk and drive home while there was still light. My brothers, Andre and Stephen, had arrived with coolers and folding chairs. My sister Patrice brought lemon pound cake and a new scarf for our mother. Children threw a football between the maple tree and the fence while my mother presided over dominoes like a judge whose rulings could not be appealed.
Her name was Lillian Whitfield. She had worked thirty-seven years as a school cafeteria manager, raised four children mostly on her own after my father died, and somehow remained convinced that nobody in the family knew how to cook unless she supervised. The year before, we had taken her to a restaurant for her birthday. She had thanked us politely and then complained that the music was too loud and the meat was overcooked. This year she wanted hamburgers, sausages, peach cobbler, dominoes, and everybody under one roof, or at least within the same fence.
I had gone to the store myself for the charcoal because my mother claimed I was the only person who bought the right kind. Around three thirty I checked the grill legs, set a bucket of water nearby, and moved the children away from the cooking area. I took the ordinary precautions I had always taken, though I could not have imagined they would matter as much as they did. By four fifteen the hamburgers were sizzling, the music played low through a speaker on the patio, and Renee had placed a red-and-white tablecloth over the food table. It was precisely the sort of afternoon a family should be able to remember without a police report attached to it.
Briar Glen had a homeowners association. Its official purpose was to maintain the entrance landscaping, the little walking path behind the houses, and the retention pond the subdivision had been built around. The original covenants covered exterior changes, nuisance conditions, and common-area maintenance, none of which made the association the police. Most residents paid their dues without much thought. Trouble began when a handful of people decided that maintaining the community meant controlling the lives inside it.
Evelyn Pike was fifty-five, wore her gray-blond hair in a smooth shoulder-length bob, and served as chair of the HOA's neighborhood standards committee. It was a volunteer position with an impressive name and very limited authority. Under the governing documents she could review reported violations, take photographs from public areas, and recommend notices to the management company. She could not enter private yards without permission, conduct interrogations, order residents to disband lawful gatherings, or make emergency calls merely because she disliked the people at a party. Evelyn did not seem to recognize those distinctions.