Not expensive. Not particularly fine. Just a narrow band polished smooth by years of being kept in a pocket. I bought it a long time ago, he said. Back when I was foolish enough to believe I might someday have a different life.
Maren looked from the ring to his face. Are you asking me to marry you? Not yet. His crooked smile appeared then faded. I can't promise I'll become a good man tomorrow, Maren, but I want you to know this isn't a game to me.
He took her hand leaving her free to pull away. I've never wanted to be worthy of anything as badly as I want to be worthy of you. Maren knew a ring could not erase a crime. She knew love was no substitute for repentance. Still, she let him slip it onto her finger.
For one quiet afternoon, she allowed herself to hope. The hope lasted three days. A frightened stable boy came forward claiming he had heard Henry Vale's murderer speak before the shooting. He recognized Luther Kincaid's voice from an argument outside the freight depot. Then a search of supplies Luther had left with a local saddler uncovered a brass-handled pocketknife.
Henry Vale's initials were scratched into its handle. His widow identified it without hesitation. Maren found Rafael at his camp beyond town. Luther killed Henry Vale. You know what you have to do.
Rafael stood beside a table scattered with maps. I'll question him. You'll hand him over. Once I know the truth, you have a witness. You have Henry's knife.
And I have a man who once dragged me out of a gunfight with a bullet in his own shoulder. Maren stared at him. That was years ago. I owe him my life, and Henry Vale lost his. Rafael flinched.
She had never seen him look so helpless. Give me a little time, he said. That's what you always ask for. Time to make things right. Time to become someone different.
Her voice trembled despite her efforts to steady it. How much time did Henry's wife get? Rafael said nothing. Maren looked down at the silver ring. She had worn it for 3 days.
Already, its small weight had become familiar. Slowly, she slipped it from her finger. You can keep your gang, Rafael, but you cannot keep me, too. She placed the ring on the table. He looked at it, then at her.
He did not reach for her hand, and somehow, that hurt worst of all. After she left, Rafael sat alone until the evening shadows swallowed the room. He had told himself loyalty made him different from men who betrayed their own. But loyalty to a murderer was not honor. It was another kind of cowardice.