Apologize. Rafael said softly. Rafael. Maren's voice was firm. He looked at her.
Let him go. For a moment, she saw something cold and terrible behind those dark eyes. Then Rafael released the man. Deputy's orders. He walked away, leaving the entire saloon silent.
Maren should have felt relieved. Instead, she wondered how much violence he had chosen not to use. Two days later, a freight wagon came careening down Main Street, its horses wild with fright. A little boy stood frozen in its path. Maren shouted.
Rafael was already moving. He leaped from his horse, seized the child, and rolled with him beneath the edge of a wooden porch as the wagon thundered past. When Maren reached them, the boy was crying but unharmed. Blood ran across Rafael's scraped knuckles. You're hurt, she said.
Boy isn't. The child's mother hurried toward them, calling her thanks. Rafael mounted before she arrived. Maren watched him ride away. She knew he had robbed men at gunpoint.
She knew there were families who would never forgive the Black Wolf. Yet she had also seen him spare a drunken fool and risk his life for a child whose name he did not know. The question troubling her was no longer whether Rafael Varela was a good man. It was whether a man could do good things and still choose to live a wicked life. She carried that question with her all the way back to the sheriff's office and before the day was over, Rafael Varela gave her another reason to ask it.
A woman named Mrs. Harlan came into the office just after noon clutching an unmarked envelope in both hands. Her husband had been driving a freight wagon when the Black Wolf's men stopped it 3 weeks earlier in the Cañon. A horse had fallen crushing his leg beneath the wagon. He had not worked since. Now, someone had left $20 at their door.
Enough to buy medicine, pay the doctor, and keep their children fed until their father could stand again. Mrs. Harlan wanted to know who had sent it. Maren looked at the money, then at the woman's trembling hands. She had a suspicion. By sundown, she had found out enough to confirm it.
She found Rafael in the livery stable brushing down his black horse. You think money makes it right? He stopped brushing. No. Then why send it?
Because I couldn't undo what happened. She had come prepared for excuses. He offered none. You could stop robbing people. Yes, he said.
The simplicity of his answer angered her more than any argument could have. Then why don't you? Rafael set the brush aside. Some roads are harder to leave than they are to enter. That's a reason.