Charles had not always been cruel in the way he joked. Before the accident, his rough humor had made long workdays easier for men who labored under him. Since the fall, however, he had made disappointment into a performance. When someone spoke of improvement, he mocked optimism. When someone expressed concern, he mocked pity. The guests were careful to laugh because refusing to laugh meant confronting a sadness they did not know how to face. Helena had grown adept at watching the room for signs of trouble, then removing him before the sadness turned into anger.
Noah's grandmother had called this kind of anger grief with its shoes on. She had been a home-health aide for thirty-seven years, most of them spent caring for people richer than herself, and she taught her grandson that suffering did not always make people gentle. Sometimes it stripped away the manners they had relied on to conceal their fear. His grandmother had died the previous winter, leaving Noah with a canvas satchel full of notebooks and a photograph of his father standing beside a running track. His mother had died when he was four. His father had been gone for five years. The rest of his life had been an assortment of couches, temporary placements, shelters, and streets.
Charles noticed him just as Noah shifted his weight to leave. "Well, who have we got back there?" he called, loud enough for the servers to stop moving. "You're a little young for the catering business." Several guests turned. Noah felt the familiar sensation of becoming a problem before he had opened his mouth. He lowered his eyes and said he was looking for the exit. Charles asked his name. When Noah answered, Charles repeated it as though the boy had been invited to introduce himself at the head table.
"Noah, are you a guest?" Charles asked. "No, sir." "Family of the staff?" "No, sir." "Then the hotel has improved its outreach program more than anyone told me." Laughter scattered around the courtyard. Noah's fingers tightened around the bread in his pocket. Helena's gaze moved from the boy's uncovered feet to his thin gray sweatshirt. She told Charles that the child should be offered a proper meal, but Charles was enjoying the audience. He asked where Noah lived, and Noah said, "Around." Charles smiled. "Around is not an address, son."
He might have let the exchange end there. Instead Charles looked down at his own left leg, adjusted his trouser cuff, and winced. Noah saw it and said, before he could make himself stop, "Does your hip hurt more after you've been sitting a long time?" The laughter faded. Charles