HOA Karen Threw Pool Parties in My Backyard While I Worked — Then I Installed a Keypad Lock

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The day after I confronted Vanessa, Julia called about a tax document she'd found among her files. We had remained friendly, or at least careful, since the divorce. I told her about the incident because it was too absurd not to mention. She listened and said, "You know what bothers me most about that? You bought that place specifically so it could be yours." I admitted I was afraid of becoming an angry man whom everyone in the neighborhood dreaded seeing. Julia was quiet for a moment. "You used to confuse being reasonable with being endlessly available," she said. "It isn't unreasonable to tell someone not to come into your backyard." I thanked her and felt an old, bittersweet sadness that we could understand some truths so clearly now that our marriage was over.

At midnight I made a list of questions. Who had a key? How often had the gatherings happened? Had Vanessa charged money, or was she simply dispensing favors to friends? Did the insurance policy cover an injury during unauthorized use? How much had I spent maintaining water other people used without my knowledge? I thought about calling the police, but by then the guests were gone and I wanted first to know whether the HOA had even claimed an easement in writing. I slept badly and woke feeling as though the house had moved a few inches away from me during the night.

At seven the next morning I found a pink sheet taped to my front door. The heading read OFFICIAL COMPLIANCE NOTICE. Beneath it, in bold type, were the words: Unauthorized restriction of shared community amenity. Required corrective action: restore access immediately. Fine assessed: five hundred dollars. It was signed Vanessa Caldwell, Association President, with a line for my acknowledgment. I read it twice and laughed once, not because anything was funny but because the alternative was throwing the paper across the driveway. She was fining me for refusing strangers access to my private backyard.

I called the management company listed on my dues statement. The receptionist transferred me twice and finally connected me to a property administrator named Elise Warren. Elise sounded young and tired. I asked whether the association owned any rights to my pool. Papers shuffled on her end. "I don't see anything in your lot file," she said. "But the president may have an amendment I haven't received." I asked how a president could assess a fine without a hearing. More papers moved. "Our usual process requires written notice and an opportunity to be heard," Elise answered carefully. "I can request the underlying violation record." She promised nothing beyond that. I thanked her, sent the notice and my deed, and copied myself on the email.

That afternoon Miguel came over with a small notebook and a bowl of oranges from his tree. He studied the notice, shook his head, and opened the notebook on my kitchen table. There were dates beside observations written in tidy block letters. May twelve, six guests. May fourteen, five guests.

News in the same category

HOA Karen Threw Pool Parties in My Backyard While I Worked — Then I Installed a Keypad Lock

30 Part