There was another reason I hesitated to confront the women immediately. The day before, Rebecca had shown me how an unauthorized gathering could become a dispute about what I had allegedly allowed. If I showed up screaming and physically pushed people toward the gate, Vanessa might describe the scene differently to the board or police. If I did nothing at all, someone might argue I had tolerated the continued use. Rebecca advised me to make clear in writing that no one had permission, preserve the recordings, and seek official help rather than turn an argument into a confrontation. I had sent an email that morning stating that access was prohibited and asking the management company to circulate the notice to the board. Vanessa had received it. On the recording she was telling guests the exact opposite.
I tried calling Miguel while watching the feed. He was at the grocery store and answered over the sound of carts and a cash register. When I told him the women were in the yard again, he cursed softly, something I'd never heard him do. He offered to go home and stand outside the gate until I arrived. I asked him not to challenge anybody. "Be a witness if you happen to see something," I said, "but don't get into trouble for me." He muttered that witnessing was his specialty and said he would return as soon as possible. I suddenly appreciated the fact that there were people willing to care about what happened at my house even when it did not directly affect them.
On the camera, the guests had arranged towels across my patio, and Vanessa was behaving like a host at a resort. She opened the outdoor storage chest where I kept sunscreen and spare towels, although she had no right to touch it. She handed one woman a clean towel and told another she could use the bathroom inside if she needed to. I hadn't mentioned that the back door was locked, and for a moment I wondered whether she had found a way into the house itself. The camera nearest the kitchen showed the door remained closed. I felt a moment of relief followed by anger that I had to be grateful a stranger had only entered my yard.
One guest, wearing dark glasses and a patterned cover-up, seemed increasingly uncomfortable. She asked Vanessa whether there was a restroom available and whether the event had a permit. Vanessa waved away the question and said an association event didn't need the same paperwork as a commercial business. She was wrong about more than one thing, but she spoke with an ease that made the answer sound familiar. The woman hesitated, then accepted another drink. That small exchange captured how Vanessa's authority worked: a question would arise, she would answer with certainty, and people would surrender their own doubts because they didn't want to seem difficult in front of friends.
When the woman in yellow approached the steps, I was watching the lower part of the feed because a glass had been set on the coping. I'd been meaning to replace the slick tile near the shallow end with a more textured surface, although the pool inspector at closing had