The notice informed me that the HOA had voted in a special emergency session I had not been notified of to assess a $500 architectural violation fee for each camera for a running total of $2,000 and that my homeowner association dues account had been placed on administrative hold, meaning I could not vote, access community amenities, or use the pool. My kids had swim passes for that pool. Delia had swim lessons every Tuesday. HOA boards in Ohio are required by state law to provide homeowners with advanced written notice of meetings where their property is on the agenda at least 10 days in advance. An emergency session to levy fines against a specific homeowner with no notice to that homeowner is about as legal as a speeding ticket written by your next door neighbor.
Takeaway, always request meeting minutes, always. I called Dale that same night. He was quiet for a long moment after I read him the notice. Then he said, in that measured voice lawyers use when they're genuinely excited, "Garrett, they just handed us a procedural violation. That meeting was improper under Ohio 5312.09 and their own bylaws.
Any fines assessed at it are voidable." I asked him what we should do. " Nothing yet,"he said. " Let them keep going. Document everything.
We want a pattern." I didn't love that answer. Delia had already cried about the swim lessons, but I trusted Dale, so I started doing something I should have done 2 years earlier. I started recording everything. Not just with the security cameras, I began keeping a written log date and time stamped of every interaction with Brenda, every notice I received, every phone call.
I bought a dedicated notebook, one of those black hardback composition books, and I labeled it HOA log volume one. I didn't know there would be a volume two, or a volume three. Meanwhile, Brenda was getting bolder. She started what I can only describe as a tour of my property. Three times in the next week, I caught her on my driveway cameras standing at the edge of my property line, taking photos with her phone, standing there in my driveway, which last I checked is not a public right of way.
The third time, I stepped outside. The air was that particular October sharp, cold enough to see your breath, leaves skittering across the concrete in little dry whispers. And Brenda stood there in her salmon-colored blazer, phone out, not even pretending to do anything other than photograph my house. Brenda, I said, "Can I help you?"" I'm conducting a compliance inspection.""
On my private driveway?" She smiled. It was the kind of smile that's made entirely of condescension. " The HOA has the right to inspect common visible surfaces at any reasonable time. It's in the CC&Rs, section six, clause one."