HOA Karen Smashed My Security Camera — Then a Deputy Watching the Livestream Called It In

Chapter 2

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

3 inches. I kept paying the fines, 25 here, 50 there. I gritted my teeth and I complied. Because I talked to a real estate attorney friend of mine, Dale Huffman, a guy I went to high school with, and Dale told me that fighting HOA violations directly was expensive, slow, and almost never went anywhere unless you could prove a pattern of selective enforcement or a procedural violation. Here's what Dale didn't know yet.

Brenda was about to give me both. It started with the break-ins. In the fall of 2022, three homes on our block, not mine, but close, got hit by car burglars. Side windows popped, center consoles emptied, garage door openers stolen. Classic smash and grab stuff.

The Pinecrest Facebook group was on fire. People were scared. So, I did what any electrician with a YouTube habit and a sense of personal responsibility does. I bought a four-camera PoE security system. Good cameras, night vision, motion alerts, two-way audio, and here's the part that matters, a live 24/7 cloud stream that I could share with a link.

I mounted one on the front porch corner post, one on the garage eave, one covering the driveway gate, and one on the backyard fence facing the alley. Brenda's letter arrived before I'd even finished sealing the conduit holes. Mr. Whitfield, the installation of surveillance equipment on exterior surfaces of your home violates section nine, clause two of the Pinecrest Estates HOA covenants. You are hereby directed to remove said equipment within 14 days or face fines of $100 per day. I read that letter four times.

Then I called Dale. And Dale said something interesting. Read section nine, clause two again, carefully, out loud. So, I did. And I found the single most important word in this entire story.

But, I'm getting ahead of myself. The 14-day clock ran down. I didn't remove the cameras. I sent Brenda a certified letter instead, one that Dale helped me draft, politely explaining that I had reviewed section nine, clause two in its entirety, and that I believed my installation was in compliance. I included two paragraphs of legal reasoning that I barely understood myself, but Dale assured me they were airtight.

I also, at Dale's suggestion, filed a request with the HOA board for a formal interpretation hearing, a right granted to every homeowner under Ohio Revised Code 5312.09. Brenda's response? She escalated. Two days after she received my certified letter, I came home from a job site smelling like PVC flux and coffee, steel-toed boots still caked with red clay from a conduit trench I'd been digging since 7:00 a.m. to find a bright orange notice taped directly to my front door. Not tucked in the door handle, taped with blue painter's tape on my freshly painted hunter green door.

News in the same category

HOA Karen Smashed My Security Camera — Then a Deputy Watching the Livestream Called It In

15 Part