HOA Karen Ordered a Man to Remove His 5,000-Gallon Water Tank — Then a Wildfire Broke Out

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The association's response did not challenge my measurements. It told me that county permission did not override the community's aesthetic expectations and scheduled a hearing. I went carrying the same folder, along with current photographs taken from each common area. Patricia chaired the meeting at a rented community room behind the volunteer fire station. Other homeowners had come to ask about shutters, paint, and a fence extension, and their items took a few minutes apiece. Mine took almost half an hour, although I was allowed to speak for less than ten minutes of it.

She introduced the tank as a 'large industrial intrusion' into the neighborhood landscape. I described its placement, safety purpose, and permitting history. A board member named Peter Sloan, a retired construction accountant, asked whether the architectural guideline actually prohibited emergency water storage. Patricia said the board did not have to anticipate every unsuitable object when the purpose of its covenants was obvious. She then looked at my boots and remarked that certain residents needed a fuller explanation of what property standards meant. The room fell silent. I asked her which published standard she believed I had violated and waited for an answer.

She repeated 'community standards' without identifying a section that directly applied. Peter made a note and suggested consulting the association attorney before imposing a continuing penalty. Patricia said the board had discussed the matter informally and there was no need to delay enforcement for one stubborn homeowner. Two members glanced at each other and then voted with her. Peter abstained, explaining that he did not have enough information. Nobody applauded. I left with a fourteen-day removal demand, a hundred dollars a day in proposed fines afterward, and the strange feeling that I had been punished for asking a question nobody wanted to answer.

Outside, an older neighbor named Arthur Vance caught up to me in the parking lot. Arthur was sixty-seven, retired from an accounting practice, and lived two houses down the slope. We had exchanged pleasant conversations over trash pickup and the deer that ate his roses, but never discussed anything serious. He asked why a five-thousand-gallon tank mattered so much to me. I told him that sometimes an emergency arrived with a working truck and no water, and that a person who had witnessed that once tended to remember it. Arthur looked toward the dark outline of the hills and asked whether I thought Pine Hollow was in danger.

'I'm not predicting a fire,' I said. 'I'm saying the neighborhood has some weaknesses we ought to understand.' Arthur nodded, then told me he had once seen a newsletter mentioning a study about emergency planning on our side of the development. He had never heard what came of it. That small remark stayed with me. I thought of the assessment in my office drawer and wondered how many other residents had been waiting for someone to explain what it meant. I went home feeling less alone, but not yet prepared to make the fight public.

The first person to call after the hearing was my sister, Denise. She had followed my business through payroll trouble, two recessions, and Evelyn's illness, and she could hear when my patience was thinning even across a telephone line. 'Please tell me you're not planning to spend the fall arguing with people who

News in the same category

HOA Karen Ordered a Man to Remove His 5,000-Gallon Water Tank — Then a Wildfire Broke Out

30 Part