Patricia's first response came before breakfast was over. An email appeared in my inbox announcing that the association considered the fence an unauthorized structure that interfered with customary circulation. It ordered immediate removal and promised escalating fines if I failed to comply. The message was copied to all board members, which seemed unwise considering how carefully she had avoided showing them earlier notices. I forwarded it to Claire and asked whether I should reply.
Claire suggested one brief response with the survey, photographs, and the exact exemption attached. She wrote that any claim of an easement should be supported by a recorded instrument identifying the property and the rights claimed. She also asked the board to preserve communications relating to the matter. I read her draft twice before sending it, because the tone was so calm that it made Patricia's threats look childish by comparison. Within an hour, Patricia replied in capital letters that the matter would be handled at the highest level.
The highest level turned out to be a man named Roger Phelps. He emailed me Monday afternoon from an address that described him as a legal consultant and warned that removing access to an established thoroughfare could lead to substantial damages. The letterhead had a brass-colored scale of justice and a line implying that Roger was counsel to the association. It demanded payment of five thousand dollars within five business days and threatened an injunction. When Claire examined the message, she found no bar number, no firm address, and no authority showing the board had hired him.
She checked the state attorney directory and learned that Roger was not licensed to practice law in our state. The name itself belonged to Patricia's cousin, a man who operated a document-preparation business outside the county. Claire sent a firm letter asking him to clarify his role and requesting that he stop representing himself as an attorney if he lacked a license. Roger answered only that he was a private consultant offering general administrative guidance. The legal threats ceased, though the emails from Patricia did not.
I said I would, but I asked him to distinguish my dispute from any financial investigation. Patricia had trespassed on my property; that did not automatically mean she'd stolen money. Michael agreed, though he sounded tired. "The problem," he said, "is that every time we ask Patricia for a record, she tells us it's confidential or already handled. She's been president so long that some people forgot the board has responsibilities separate from her." He promised to send a formal notice of a meeting once the directors had enough information.
Elena took the news with a mixture of satisfaction and worry. She had spent more than two years watching people keep quiet because challenging Patricia meant receiving notices about harmless things. Elena herself had once been fined over a garden bench painted bright blue. She had paid it because she was recovering from surgery and lacked the energy to argue. When I told her the board might review old penalties, she retrieved the receipt from a biscuit tin where she kept important papers and placed it beside her notebook of strange arrivals.