In early winter, the prosecutor's office asked me to give a formal interview about my history with Evelyn. An assistant prosecutor named Naomi Pierce explained that she needed careful facts: what Evelyn had said, what letters she'd sent, what I understood at the time, and how I responded. She discouraged guesses about Evelyn's motives. I described the seven notices, the first board meeting, the threatened towing, and the day the lock was cut. Naomi asked whether I had ever given anyone permission to enter the garage or remove the Jeep. I answered no. The simplicity of that answer seemed to matter more than any speech I could have delivered.
When she asked about my father, I struggled. The personal value of the Wrangler did not determine whether the entry had been lawful, and Naomi did not pretend otherwise. But it explained why the loss had hurt. I told her about the roadside apple stand, the dent in the hood, and the promise Dad had asked me to make. She listened without looking at her notes for a long moment. Then she thanked me and asked whether I would be willing to testify if the case went to trial. I said yes. I had not chosen any of this, but I could choose to tell the truth when asked.
The first frost came early. Maple leaves piled against the new garage threshold, and the Wrangler spent more time inside while salt trucks began their winter routes. Evelyn's house remained immaculate. A holiday wreath hung on the door, and the porch lights came on at precisely six each evening. She rarely appeared outside. Martin sometimes walked to the mailbox with his head down, collecting envelopes without looking toward our house. I found myself wondering whether he had known about the tow or the money. Then I remembered Luis's advice and left those questions where they belonged, with the investigators.
In December the board's independent counsel announced that significant findings had been referred to law enforcement. The association retained a specialist to reconstruct the financial records and authorized a claim against any responsible parties if the evidence supported it. Residents were understandably furious, especially those who had paid repeated fines. But the acting board resisted demands to announce criminal conclusions before the investigation had finished. Leah called that restraint the most encouraging sign yet. Maple Ridge was learning that leadership could mean declining to say more than the facts allowed.
I spent a Saturday morning replacing the Jeep's bent tie-down bracket and touching up the scrape on its bumper. Ben came over from the shop with a better set of tools, refusing payment and accepting Leah's coffee instead. We worked in companionable silence until he asked whether I had considered selling the Wrangler once the case was over. He did not mean to offend me. He wondered whether keeping it would always bring back the memory of the theft. I thought for a moment. 'If I let that day decide whether I keep it,' I said, 'then Evelyn gets to make another decision for me.' Ben nodded, handed me a wrench, and said nothing more.