He was checking the cinch on his saddle and he kept his hands on the leather and his eyes on the task. "What did you say?" he asked. "Sir, when they said it, what did you say back?" Billy straightened up.
"I said she fixed the water barrel and reorganized the larder and is doing the ledgers and the place runs better already." He paused. Mrs. Rener said that proves she had nowhere else to go. Ethan finished with the cinch, put his foot in the stirrup. Mounted, "Next time Mrs. Rener has an opinion about my household."
He said, "You can tell her. I don't recall asking." He wrote out. Billy watched him go with the expressions of someone storing that sentence away for future use. Clara heard the town's opinion for herself on Saturday.
She was in the merkantile in the canned goods aisle when two women's voices came around the shelf from the other side. Clear as water, unhurried. The way people speak when they've forgotten or don't care that walls are thin and aisles are short. Plain, isn't she? Well, he didn't exactly advertise for beauty.
A woman with any prospects doesn't answer a telegram like that. Father was a drinker, I heard. Laramie whole family was a small particular pause, the kind that speaks volumes well. You know, Clara picked up a tin of coffee, set it in her basket, up a second tin, set it in her basket. Her hands were steady.
Her face was composed. She had a great deal of practice at this particular skill, keeping her exterior still while the interior did whatever it needed to do. She went to the counter and paid. Outside, she loaded the wagon. Then she sat on the bench and let herself have exactly 30 seconds.
30 seconds to feel at the old familiar sting of being found insufficient by people who had not taken 30 minutes to learn her name. 30 seconds to let it be what it was, which was painful and unfair and also completely irrelevant to who she actually was. Then she picked up the reinss and drove back to the ranch. 30 seconds was what she allowed it. Not one more.
That evening, she asked him the question she'd been holding since the first day. He was at the table with his coffee and the corrected ledgers, going over the figures she'd prepared. She sat down across from him without asking. "Why a mail order arrangement?" she said.
He looked up. "There must have been women in Bitter Creek willing to marry you, " she said. "You're not an impossible man." He considered that for a moment, like he was deciding how honest to be. There were women willing, he said finally.
It wasn't the problem. Then what was? He sat down the coffee, both hands flat on the table. The posture of a man choosing words the way a person chooses footing on bad ground deliberately, one step at a time. A woman from this town comes with a history in this town, he said, of people who've known her all her life.