The sheriff listened carefully when Jonah reported the damage. Caleb Marsh had served Mercy Creek for nearly twenty years, enough to know that wealth could silence decent people without buying a single badge. He had heard rumors about Harlan's interest in the eastern farms, but a businessman making low offers was not, by itself, proof of criminal conduct. He recorded Jonah's observations and asked whether anyone had actually seen the theft. Jonah said not yet. Marsh replied that he would investigate, though his two deputies were already stretched thin by cattle thefts in the northern country.
On the trail back, Jonah found a broken spoke beside fresh wagon tracks near an abandoned charcoal kiln. A strip of blue harness cloth had snagged on a branch, and the wheel ruts matched the heavy wagon he had seen Martin Sloane drive the previous week. Farther down, the ground showed signs that a loaded wagon had stopped abruptly. He found one iron fitting half buried in loose dirt. The object was stamped with the mark of Amos Vickers's forge, which was enough to place the stolen material on the trail but not enough to prove who had taken it.
He returned to the creek with the evidence wrapped in cloth. Clara looked at the fitting and said Amos had made a dozen like it for her. Jonah asked whether anybody else in the valley had purchased the same pattern, and she admitted she did not know. Eli listened from the wagon, unusually quiet. Later, when Clara was cooking, he told Jonah that he had seen a man on a gray horse by the bridge two nights earlier and recognized a bright copper concho on the bridle. Jonah wrote down the description but told Eli not to go looking for the rider himself.
The next afternoon Harlan's cattle broke through a fence near the unfinished crossing. The first warning came from a boy riding hard from the western pasture, shouting that the animals had turned downhill toward the creek. Jonah mounted and rode to intercept them while Clara fetched the wagon and drove with Eli along the upper bank. Dust rose behind the herd, and the cattle were nervous from the cold wind and unfamiliar obstacles. Their movement was not an organized stampede so much as a frightened, crowded rush that could become dangerous wherever the ground narrowed.
Jonah turned most of the animals toward an open meadow. One enormous steer broke from the line and charged down the approach, striking a temporary barrier hard enough to split its braces. The trestle shifted with a dry cracking sound, and Clara saw the half-set crossbeam beginning to roll. She climbed onto the stable end of the work platform with a rope, trying to secure it before the timber dropped into the creek. The beam moved faster than she expected. Jonah reached her just as the support twisted, caught her by the waist, and dragged her clear while wood and iron crashed into the water below.
They landed against the muddy bank, Jonah taking most of the impact. For a moment the air left both of them, and Clara could hear only Eli calling her name. Blood ran from her forearm, where a projecting spike had torn through her sleeve, but the cut was not deep. She tried to sit up and look at the damage. Jonah stopped her long enough to make sure she could move her fingers, then helped her onto solid ground.