Every Woman Wanted the Mysterious Cowboy — Then One Woman Stepped Into the Street and Said, “You’re a Fraud.”

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Shoot a woman in broad daylight in front of 50 witnesses. See how far you get on that stolen stage horse before they hang you from the livery rafters." "Shut your mouth," Wyatt hissed, his hand trembling slightly. It was the first time anyone in Oak Haven had heard genuine raw emotion in his voice. It wasn't the gravelly, seductive tone he had weaponized.

It was the high, tight pitch of a man out of options. "Drop the iron, son." The booming voice of Sheriff Amos Caldwell shattered the standoff. The older lawman had stepped off the boardwalk. A double-barreled shotgun pressed firmly to his shoulder, aimed squarely at Wyatt's head.

Behind him, the town's blacksmith stepped out, gripping a heavy iron hammer, and two other men unholstered their sidearms. "You got three seconds to drop that Colt," Sheriff Caldwell warned, his thumb resting on the twin hammers of his shotgun. "One." Wyatt's eyes darted wildly around the street. He was surrounded.

The very women who had baked him pies and mended his shirts were now staring at him with utter revulsion and terror. Two," the sheriff barked. Wyatt swallowed hard. The fight drained out of him all at once. He lowered the revolver, popped the cylinder open, and let the bullets spill into the dust before tossing the empty weapon aside.

He raised his hands in surrender. 10 minutes later, Wyatt, now stripped of his gun belt, and his stoic mystique, sat in the cramped, stifling heat of the town jailhouse. Sheriff Caldwell stood by the grated window, chewing on a matchstick. Joe stood near the doorway, her arms crossed tight over her chest, refusing to leave until she had the whole story. "My name is Dalton Reynolds," he finally said, staring at the scarred wooden floorboards of his cell.

"I didn't ride with the Denver gang by choice. I was forced." "Nobody forces a man to hold up the Overland stage," Caldwell said flatly. "They do when they have your brother," Dalton replied, his voice cracking. He looked up, and for the first time, the anguish on his face wasn't a calculated parlor trick.

"His name is William, he's 14." He got tangled up in a bad gambling debt in Colorado with a man named Dave Rudabore, joe stiffened. Even she knew that name. Dave Rudabore was a notorious real life rustler and killer who rode with some of the most vicious gangs in the territory. He was a man who left a trail of burned-out ranches and dead deputies in his wake.

Rudabore took William, Dalton continued, burying his face in his hands. Told me I had to pull the stage coach job and bring him $10,000 or he'd put a bullet in the boy's head. I did the job. I took the money and the roan mare, but things went south. The posse was too close.

I had to stash the lockbox in a ravine 50 miles south of here and lay low. He looked at Joe, his eyes pleading. "I came to Oak Haven to hide until the heat died down." I didn't mean to play anyone for a fool, but when I got here, everyone, they just projected this tragic story onto me. It was the perfect cover.

News in the same category

Every Woman Wanted the Mysterious Cowboy — Then One Woman Stepped Into the Street and Said, “You’re a Fraud.”

8 Part