The bell above the door chimed and the atmosphere in the room shifted instantly. Two women lingering by the bolts of calico fabric suddenly hushed, their eyes darting toward the towering cowboy. Wyatt walked to the counter. Up close, Joe had to admit the sheer physical presence of the man was overwhelming. He smelled of leather, woodsmoke, and rain.
He placed a small slip of paper on the counter. "Morning," he murmured. His voice was a low, gravelly rasp, the kind of voice that made the women by the fabric bolts physically shiver. Joe didn't shiver. She picked up the paper, her hazel eyes scanning the list.
Flour, sugar, a heavy canvas tarp, 50 rounds of.44-caliber ammunition, and a very specific, expensive brand of imported cigarillos. She looked up, meeting his bruised sky eyes. "I'm out of the imported cigarillos. I have standard tobacco, and you owe me for last month's sugar." Wyatt blinked, momentarily taken aback.
Clearly, he was used to women tripping over themselves to accommodate him. He leaned slightly over the counter, closing the distance between them, utilizing the brooding, intimate proximity that usually melted the local ladies. "Is that right?" He asked softly, letting a hint of vulnerability slip into his tone. "Times are a bit tough up on the ridge, Miss Mercer.
I was hoping for a short extension." "I run a supply store, Mr. Callahan, not a charity," Joe replied, her voice ringing out clearly across the quiet store. The women by the fabric gasped. "Your bill is $3.40. You can pay it now, or you can put these goods back on the shelf."
A flash of genuine irritation broke through Wyatt's stoic facade, but it vanished as quickly as it appeared. He reached into his coat, pulled out a worn leather coin purse, and slapped four silver dollars onto the oak counter. "Keep the change," he said, turning on his heel. "I will," Joe called out to his retreating back. "It'll go toward the late fee."
As the door swung shut behind him, Joe looked down at his list. She tapped her pencil against the wood, a deep frown creasing her forehead. A man claiming poverty didn't buy imported cigarillos. And a lonely, grieving widower didn't need 50 rounds of ammunition and a heavy canvas tarp in the middle of a peaceful spring. Wyatt Callahan wasn't grieving.
He was preparing for something. By midsummer, the tension in Oak Haven had thickened like the heavy humid air before a thunderstorm. The obsession with Wyatt Callahan had reached a fever pitch. A rivalry had broken out between Abigail Reed and a newcomer, a wealthy woman from Boston named Caroline Harper. They were practically waging a cold war over who could invite him to Sunday dinner.
Wyatt accepted their hospitality, ate their prime beef, let them stable his horse, and offered only deep, sorrowful glances in return. But Joe was watching him, and the closer she looked, the more the pieces of the lonely cowboy failed to fit together. It started with the horses. Joe was delivering a shipment of nails to the livery stable when she saw Wyatt bringing his black gelding in for a shoeing. While the blacksmith was working, Wyatt slipped into the back stall.
Joe, hidden behind a stack of hay bales, watched as Wyatt checked on a second horse, a beautiful, restless roan mare. He didn't just check on it. He fed it a sugar cube, and whispered to it in a hurried, frantic tone. The mare bore a brand Joe had never seen before, a double diamond with a slash through it. The second clue came during the annual Oak Haven Founders Day dance.