Murray shook his head, a masterclass in feigned exhaustion. I tried to deescalate, Your Honor. I really did. I calmly explained the reason for the stop, but she refused to produce identification. "Is that when the situation escalated?"
Yes. She suddenly reached over toward the passenger side glove compartment. Her movements were frantic, concealed from my line of sight. Given the lighting, the neighborhood, and her erratic behavior, I had a reasonable, articulated fear for my safety. I didn't know if she was reaching for a weapon.
Judge Mitchell paused his writing and looked over his glasses at Murray. "You believed she had a firearm, officer?" "I had to assume the worst to protect myself, Your Honor," Murray lied smoothly. I ordered her out of the vehicle. She refused.
I opened the door to physically extract her for my own safety. That's when she struck me. She clawed at my uniform, kicked my shin, and attempted to flee on foot. I had to use necessary physical force to restrain her and place her in handcuffs. "Thank you, Officer Murray.
No further questions." Hayes sat down, looking immensely satisfied. Alan Wells stood up on shaky legs. He walked to the podium, his notes trembling slightly in his hands. "Officer Murray, you state my client was swerving, but the road was heavily potholed on that stretch of Elm Street, wasn't it?
Is it possible she was simply avoiding road hazards?" "I know the difference between avoiding a pothole and driving under the influence, counselor," Murray sneered, leaning forward. "Yet, the breathalyzer administered at the station showed a blood alcohol level of 0.00. Furthermore, no weapon was found in her vehicle. In fact, she was reaching for her registration, which she kept in the glove box exactly as you asked her to do. "She moved aggressively.
I don't wait to see the barrel of a gun before I react. If I did, I wouldn't go home to my family." And your dash cam, officer, Murray, why was it turned off during this specific traffic stop? Murray shrugged. An easy, dismissive gesture.
"Equipment malfunction. The department is underfunded. We've been complaining to dispatch about those cameras for months. It's unfortunate, but it happens." "It happens quite frequently with you, doesn't it?"
Alan pushed, finding a momentary spark of courage. In fact, in your last four arrests involving minority defendants, your camera magically malfunctioned every single time. "Objection," Hayes barked, shooting out of his chair. Relevance. Counselor is badgering the witness and attempting to smear Officer Murray's decorated record with baseless insinuations.