A Woman Told the Waitress Only Serves Dinner — Then She Sat at the Grand Piano

Chapter 7

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Ruth's hands began to stiffen the winter Claire turned twenty-one. Arthritis, the doctor said, common, manageable, a word that minimized the look on Ruth's face when a simple accompaniment hiccuped under her fingers. She stopped taking the youngest beginners. She kept the serious ones. She sat on her hands in the evenings to warm them, a sight Claire could not stand and could not look away from.

"Don't narrate my knuckles," Ruth said. "Play me the Brahms. The A major. And don't make it prettier than it is. I can still hear."

The Intermezzo Op. 118 No. 2 was Ruth's piece the way some people have a hymn they don't advertise. It did not show off. It carried a melody that kept almost resolving and then thought better of it, a tenderness that had backbone. Claire worked it until Voss, who did not care about family mythology, said, "All right. That's not a souvenir. That's a performance."

There was a boy in those years, a violinist named Seth who wanted Claire to be easier in restaurants and more impressed by his plans. He told her, kindly, that she could be happy if she stopped treating every phrase like a referendum on her right to exist. He was not entirely wrong. Claire ended it anyway, on a Thursday, because she did not want a life in which her work was a personality flaw someone loved her in spite of. Seth said she would regret the severity. She regretted, later, the way she had said goodbye, which was clean to the point of cold. She did not regret the Thursday.

In the fall she was twenty-three, a recital set forming, a small residency in Chicago offered for the following year: teaching three days, playing community concerts, the sort of beginning that is not famous and is not nothing. She called Ruth from a practice room with the offer letter folded in her lap.

"Take it," Ruth said. The connection made her voice thinner. "You come home to eat, not to hover. We agreed."

"Your hands."

"My hands are my business. Your life is yours. Don't you dare make me the reason you become careful."

Claire said she would take it. She meant it. Then in November Ruth's heart, which had been a quiet complaint for a year, stopped being quiet. Not a stroke. Not the swift plot Claire had braced for since Paul. Congestive heart failure, the doctor said, a phrase that sounded like a moral accusation and was only a description of a muscle doing less than the body asked. The house acquired a pill organizer and a scale and a new kind of waiting. Claire deferred the residency. Voss did not congratulate her on the deferral. Voss said, "Go home. Keep your hands honest while you're there. Grief is a sloppy editor. Don't let it cut the bass."

She moved back into her old room. The reindeer sweater was long gone. The Baldwin was still there. She played in the afternoons while Ruth rested on the couch with her eyes closed, conducting sometimes with one finger, stopping Claire when the melody asked for pity.

"I don't want pity," Ruth said. "Pity is sharp in the wrong places. Play me the truth. If the truth is sad, fine. Sadness is not the same as sagging."

"You should have been the one with the scarf and the students in Cleveland."

"I had the students I wanted," Ruth said. "One of them is currently insulting my life choices. Again from the second system."

March came with dirty snow and a hospital that smelled like warm plastic and chicken soup no one had ordered. Claire learned the cafeteria's coffee, which was never hot enough, and the chair that did not stab her back, and the way nurses spoke when they were leaving room in the day for bad news. She played, badly, on a lobby piano that was out of tune, until a volunteer asked her to stop because a family nearby was crying and the music made the crying harder. Claire understood. She stopped. She added it to the list of times stopping was the decent thing.

News in the same category

A Woman Told the Waitress Only Serves Dinner — Then She Sat at the Grand Piano

20 Part