After that the house was quieter in a way that had nothing to do with volume. Ruth still taught. Claire still practiced. Paul was not in the doorway. Sometimes Claire played a rag anyway, too loud, and Ruth did not tell her to bring it down. That was grief too, the permission.
Scholarships were discussed at the kitchen table with brochures that looked richer than the table. Ruth wanted Cleveland. She did not want Claire across the country being brave and broke in a city that would not know the sag of their porch. The Cleveland Institute accepted her. The money was not everything, but it was enough if Claire worked summers and if Ruth kept the school job and the private students and did not get proud about accepting a church stipend for accompanying.
"Don't you dare come home to save me," Ruth said, the week they packed the car. "Come home to eat. Those are different errands."
"You could say you'd miss me."
"I could say a lot of things and still pay a mortgage I don't have," Ruth said. Then she put her palm on Claire's bun, which was not yet a bun, only a ponytail, and left it there a second longer than efficiency required. "I will miss you in the afternoons. The house likes a metronome. Go."
The practice rooms at the Institute were underground in spirit even when they had windows. They smelled of dust, valve oil from someone else's life, and the particular warm plastic of headphones students used when they were trying not to hate each other. Claire learned the geography of ambition: who warmed up in scales like a religion, who warmed up by playing the hardest passage badly until it surrendered, who cried and then pretended the crying was allergies. She was not the best pianist in the building. She was a pianist who came back the next day. Dr. Lena Voss noticed the coming back before she noticed the talent, or she pretended to, which was its own pedagogy.
Voss was in her fifties then, with cropped gray hair and a scarf she wore even in overheated rooms, as if drafts were a moral condition. She spoke in short sentences that left a mark.
"You rush where you feel safe," she said, after Claire's first month. "Safety is not a tempo marking."
"I was trying to sing."
"Singing is not an excuse for leaving your bass behind. The bass is the adult in the room. Don't abandon the adult because the melody is pretty."
Claire went back to the room in the basement and played the left hand alone until the pretty part got lonely and agreed to cooperate. This was the real training, the part people meant when they said years and did not mean the poster of a child at a concert grand. Years were Tuesdays. Years were the same eight measures, ugly, then less ugly, then suddenly, for no reason the ego could claim, clear. Years were Voss saying "again" without cruelty and without comfort, which forced Claire to locate her own.
She waited tables in the summers at a cafe near Ruth's school, a place with pies under glass and a radio that played country in the morning and nothing in the afternoon because the owner liked the sound of plates. Claire's hands blistered in a different pattern than practice blisters. She learned to smile at people who snapped their fingers. She learned that being good at a service job was a skill with its own pride, and that the pride had to be watched or it would turn into a speech she gave herself to avoid practicing. At night she played on the Baldwin until the neighbor on the right flicked a porch light, their agreed signal, and Claire closed the fallboard at ten-thirty like a promise.