That evening, Samuel rode to town alone.
Sheriff Collins listened without laughing.
That already made him different from Amos Bell and most of Red Creek.
But Collins had two deputies and a territory larger than some eastern counties.
“I can ride out tomorrow,” he said. “Tonight I’ve got one deputy escorting a prisoner south and another laid up with a broken wrist.”
“They’ll move cattle before tomorrow.”
“Maybe.”
“Wade Mercer won’t wait around.”
Collins leaned back.
“You certain it’s Mercer?”
Samuel thought about Clara’s eyes.
“Certain enough.”
The sheriff studied him.
“I’ll come at first light.”
Samuel rode home frustrated.
Clara was waiting by the barn.
She looked behind him.
No sheriff.
Samuel shook his head.
Tomorrow.
Clara’s mouth tightened.
Then she pointed toward the northern pasture.
Samuel followed her gaze.
Cattle were restless.
Not frightened.
Uneasy.
Boone stood rigid near the fence.
Clara touched Samuel’s arm.
Her hand made the sign for danger.
Then tonight.
Samuel understood.
They prepared without speaking.
Samuel checked his rifle.
Clara filled two canteens.
He loaded cartridges.
She shuttered the house.
At one point, Samuel looked at her.
“You stay inside.”
Clara shook her head.
“Clara.”
She signed:
My eyes.
Samuel signed back badly:
My ranch.
She pointed to herself.
Then the house.
Then Samuel.
Ours.
Samuel froze.
Clara looked almost embarrassed by the sign.
But she did not take it back.
Something inside Samuel shifted.
For six years, the ranch had been his because nobody else remained.
Now someone had chosen the word ours.
He nodded.
Together.
They hid near the north pasture after moonrise.
Hours passed.
Samuel heard insects, wind, cattle, distant coyotes.
Clara heard none of it.
But around midnight, she touched his arm sharply.
He looked at her.
She pointed toward the ground.
Samuel felt nothing.
Clara pressed his palm against a flat stone.
There.
A faint vibration.
Hooves.
Riders appeared minutes later.
Four men came through the lifted fence.
Two moved toward the herd.
One remained on the ridge.
The fourth rode directly toward Samuel’s barn as if checking whether the rancher was asleep.
Samuel recognized Wade Mercer even in moonlight.
Tall.
Long coat.
Flat-brimmed hat.
Samuel raised his rifle.
Clara grabbed his wrist.
He looked at her, angry for half a second.
Then she pointed.
Not at the men.
At the canyon.
She drew two fingers along the dirt like a path.
Then closed her hand.
Trap.
Samuel understood.
If he fired now, four men could scatter across open land.
If Mercer believed the ranch was unwatched, he might drive the stolen cattle toward the canyon holding point.
Then lawmen could block the only usable exit.
Samuel lowered the rifle.
It was one of the hardest things he had ever done.
They watched the thieves move twelve cattle through the fence.
Samuel’s jaw clenched so hard it hurt.
Clara touched his shoulder once.
Wait.
The thieves headed north.
Samuel and Clara circled east, keeping the ridge between them and Mercer’s men.
They rode hard toward Red Creek.
At the sheriff’s office, Clara was the one who saw the lantern moving inside before Samuel pounded on the door.
Collins opened it half-dressed and furious until he saw their faces.
“They’re moving now?”
Samuel nodded.
“Toward the canyon.”
“How many?”
“Four tonight. Could be more waiting.”
Collins woke his available deputy and sent the livery boy to fetch two ranchers he trusted.
Within twenty minutes, six riders headed north.
Clara rode with them.
Collins objected.
Samuel did too.
Clara ignored both.
At the canyon, dawn had begun thinning the eastern sky.
Clara led them not to the main trail, but to a narrow shelf above the southern exit.
Collins frowned.
“There’s a way out here?”
Clara nodded.
Samuel translated her signs.
“One rider can pass. Maybe two. Hidden from the canyon floor.”
“How’d she see that?”
Samuel looked at Clara.
“She looks.”
They divided.
Collins and two men blocked the main mouth.
Samuel, Clara, and another rancher took the shelf trail.
The plan almost worked perfectly.
Almost.