Abigail looked at him for a long time. She told him that gratitude could be mistaken for love when a person was frightened, and she would not make that mistake with her children's future. Caleb understood, though the answer hurt more than he expected. "Then we won't decide anything while you're frightened," he said. "We'll get your land back, and afterward you can choose where you want to live." She reached for his hand then, not to promise anything, but to thank him for giving her a choice.
The town's winter supper took place in the church hall on a Friday when the roads were finally clear. Abigail hesitated over attending because she knew Gideon would be there, but Thomas wanted to see the lanterns and Elsie had been promised a dance. Caleb arrived at the kitchen door in a clean dark coat and offered his arm as though escorting her were the most natural thing in the world. She wore a blue dress she had repaired herself, and when he looked at her he forgot what he had meant to say. Noah rescued him by asking whether there would be pie, which made everyone laugh and sent them out into the cold together.
At the supper, Gideon made sure their entrance did not pass unnoticed. He approached with several men from the cattle association and asked loudly whether Abigail had forgotten how recently Samuel had died. The hall fell quiet around them. Abigail felt the old impulse to apologize for occupying space, but Thomas's small hand found hers and held tight. "I haven't forgotten a single day of my marriage," she said. "I also haven't forgotten that you threatened to take my children from me. If you wish to discuss either matter, you can do it before the judge."
Gideon turned to Caleb and accused him of using a vulnerable widow to gain control of Cedar Creek. Caleb's face tightened, but he remembered Abigail's warning against giving Gideon a public fight. "She works for wages," he said. "Her decisions belong to her. And if you have evidence against her, bring it to court rather than frightening children at supper." Miriam Bell stepped forward and invited the family to her table, pulling out extra chairs without waiting for anyone's permission. Others followed her lead, and the whispering changed from scandal to a question Gideon had never expected anyone to ask: why was he so determined to take a small ranch from his brother's widow?
Later, when a fiddler began playing, Caleb asked Abigail to dance. She glanced around at the watching neighbors and said they would only gossip more. "They'll gossip if we sit," he answered. "They might as well have something worth seeing." She laughed and took his hand. He was an awkward dancer who counted under his breath, but he guided her carefully across the floor while Thomas and Elsie watched with delight. Gideon left before the music ended, and Abigail discovered that the world did not collapse when she allowed herself one happy evening.