A Cop Tackled a 17-Year-Old for Reaching for His Phone — Then the Body Cam Showed a Phone

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The judge sentenced Dempsey at a hearing that drew press coverage from across the state. 2 years for the assault on a minor. 18 months consecutive for the false arrest. 2 years consecutive for being on duty under the influence.

18 months consecutive for the false incident report. 2 years consecutive for misconduct in public office. The total sentence was 9 years, and the judge recommended that Dempsey serve at least 6 before being considered for release. His law enforcement certification was permanently revoked the same day the sentence was delivered, and he would never be permitted to work in any law enforcement capacity again.

The civil lawsuit settled 3 weeks after the criminal conviction. The department's legal team had reviewed the evidence after the verdict and reached the conclusion that a civil trial would produce a result that was at least as damaging as settling, and that the institutional liability created by allowing Dempsey to be on patrol in an impaired state made the department's exposure significant beyond just the individual incident. The settlement totaled $1 million: Austin's family received $650,000, and Chloe's family received $350,000. Neither settlement came with a non-disclosure requirement because both families had refused to sign anything that prevented them from speaking publicly about what had happened.

The department implemented mandatory random drug testing for all officers on active patrol as a direct result of the case. The policy was included in the settlement agreement as a binding commitment rather than a voluntary reform. And the testing program was overseen by an independent medical body rather than the department itself. New protocols were also established requiring supervisors to assess officer conduct in real time and to remove any officer from patrol whose behavior during a shift raised concerns.

The three prior complaints against Dempsey that had been reviewed and minimized became the centerpiece of a broader review of how the department handled complaint patterns. And the review produced a restructured complaint process with mandatory escalation timelines and consequences for repeated substantiated complaints. Austin Dixon used a portion of the settlement to establish a small fund that paid legal consultation fees for black teenagers and their families who experienced racial profiling by law enforcement in their city. He named it after the date of the incident, not because he wanted to remember it, but because he wanted other families to have access to what his family had been fortunate enough to already have when it happened to them.

When he finished his senior year of high school the following spring and graduated, his father stood in the audience with the particular pride of a man who had watched his son be treated as less than he was and had fought to ensure the treatment had consequences. Chloe spoke at a school assembly about what she had witnessed and about what it meant to her that her words had been dismissed entirely by an officer who had already decided what he was seeing before he had asked a single question. She said that being told she was being forced to say Austin was her boyfriend repeatedly, and by an adult in authority was something she thought about often. She said it had changed how she understood certain things about the world.

Five years after the incident, Dempsey was still serving his sentence. Austin was in his second year of college. The department's random drug testing program had been in place for four years and had identified two additional officers with undisclosed substance issues before either had been involved in an incident involving a civilian. The body cam footage of the evening in Riverside Park was used in law enforcement training programs in three states as an example of how racial bias combined with impaired judgment produces outcomes that destroy careers, cost departments millions, and leave teenagers with injuries and memories that no apology can undo.

News in the same category

A Cop Tackled a 17-Year-Old for Reaching for His Phone — Then the Body Cam Showed a Phone

8 Part