The third had come from a supervisor within the department who had noted in a written report that Dempsey's behavior during a specific shift had seemed inconsistent with his normal conduct, a description that now carried new weight in light of the drug test results. All three complaints had been reviewed. None had resulted in suspension or serious disciplinary action. The pattern had been documented and minimized, and Dempsey had continued working until the evening he tackled a 17-year-old boy for reaching into his pocket in a public park.
The criminal referral was made to the District Attorney's Office 2 weeks after the incident, and the DA's office reviewed the body cam footage, the drug test results, and the prior complaint history before deciding to pursue charges. Dempsey was charged with assault on a minor, conducting a false arrest, being on duty under the influence of a controlled substance, filing a false incident report in which he described Austin as having reached for a weapon, and misconduct in public office. The charges were announced publicly, and the body cam footage was released to the media the same day. The footage spread nationally within hours.
The clip that circulated most widely was 44 seconds long and showed the moment Austin said he was calling his father, his hand moving toward his pocket, and Dempsey's lunge, tackle, and the moment Austin hit the grass. 44 seconds that captured everything anyone needed to understand what had happened in Riverside Park that evening. Chloe gave a brief interview in which she said she had told Dempsey at least four times that Austin was her boyfriend and that he had not listened to a single word she said. She said that watching Austin be tackled and handcuffed for reaching for his phone was something she was still processing weeks later.
She said that the apology the other officers had given them that night was appreciated but that it had not changed what had happened. Austin did not give an interview. His father gave one on his behalf and said that his son had been on a date and had been assaulted by a police officer for it. And that the family intended to pursue every available legal remedy until there was accountability that matched the severity of what had been done to a 17-year-old boy on a Saturday evening in a public park.
The civil lawsuit was filed the following week, naming Dempsey personally, the department, and the city for institutional liability. The combined damages sought across both families' suits totaled $1 million, and the filing included every piece of evidence the investigation had produced. Russell Dempsey's criminal trial took place 5 months after the incident and lasted 5 days. The prosecution built its case on three pillars that the defense team spent the entire trial failing to dismantle the body cam footage, the drug test results, and the prior complaint history.
The jury watched the body cam footage on the first day of the trial and the 44-second clip that had already been seen by millions of people online was played in a courtroom where 12 jurors watched it without distraction and without the ability to scroll past it. They saw Austin reach for his pocket. They saw the phone. They saw Dempsey's lunge.
They heard Austin say he was 17 on the ground in the grass. They heard Chloe scream. They heard Dempsey say Austin was reaching for a weapon when the footage clearly showed otherwise. The drug test results were presented by a toxicologist who explained in plain terms what the substance in Dempsey's system did to human judgment and perception at the levels recorded in his test.
The expert described how the impairment would have affected his ability to assess situations accurately, his emotional regulation, and his capacity to respond proportionally to what was in front of him. The defense tried to argue that the substance could have been consumed after the incident rather than before, but the toxicology evidence established timing that contradicted that argument completely, and the expert held firm under cross-examination. The jury deliberated for 2 days and returned guilty verdicts on every charge: assault on a minor, conducting a false arrest, on duty under the influence of a controlled substance, filing a false incident report, misconduct in public office. Five convictions delivered in sequence in a courtroom that was full for the reading of each one.