Pike had spent years operating near legal boundaries and thought he could recognize when a case was turning. The invoices linking him to harassment of witnesses were damaging. The records involving Evelyn Rhodes were worse. He contacted an attorney and asked what cooperation might mean if he could identify the person who had arranged the surveillance and describe the orders he had received. The attorney told him no agreement was guaranteed and that misleading investigators would make matters worse. Pike eventually agreed to a proffer interview, where information could be evaluated under conditions negotiated by counsel without promising immunity.
He admitted that Lang had directed him to gather information about employees raising complaints and to pressure them into silence. He claimed the original assignments were lawful background checks, but his own records showed increasingly invasive surveillance. When asked about Naomi's son, he acknowledged hiring a contractor to photograph the university campus and identify Jonah's routine. He claimed the photograph sent to Naomi was intended as a warning, not a threat of physical harm. The distinction was not persuasive to anyone who had seen what such a warning does to a mother.
Pike also admitted that a contact had asked Keller to approach Naomi at West Haven. He said the officer was not told about the larger procurement investigation, only that Naomi might be transporting stolen medical supplies and needed to be questioned aggressively. There was evidence of a promised payment through a third party, but investigators still needed to establish whether Keller received it and whether he knew the accusation was false. Pike claimed he had never instructed anyone to use pepper spray. The claim might have been true. It did not erase his role in arranging an intimidating encounter under false pretenses.
The most difficult questions concerned Evelyn. Pike acknowledged that his company had tracked her schedule and that Lang was angry she continued filing reports. He also described a conversation about discouraging her from meeting an outside adviser. But he denied ordering or participating in any collision. He said the hit-and-run had frightened him because he wondered whether one of the contractors had acted independently. Investigators asked for names, vehicles, dates, and records. Pike provided a list, some details of which could be checked. For Naomi and Rachel, the result was agonizing. The evidence now made it harder to treat Evelyn's death as an unrelated accident, but it still fell short of proving a deliberate killing.
A traffic investigator named Deborah Finch had worked the original collision case. She had been dissatisfied with the limited evidence but could not identify the fleeing vehicle from the blurry security image available at the time. When the federal team contacted her, she reviewed the old file and agreed