A Cop Forced a Disabled Man to the Ground — Then the Bodycam Showed His Hands Were Up

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

To Leonard, it was a tool. To Maddox, for a few seconds, it had become a gun because Maddox had decided first and looked second.

Darnell sat across from him at the kitchen table. "I'm filing the complaint tonight."

Leonard nodded. "Do it."

"You want to talk to a lawyer too?"

"Eventually. First I want the video preserved."

Darnell looked at him. "You think they'll lose it?"

Leonard considered the question. "I think systems protect themselves unless someone makes protection harder than truth."

At the department, Sergeant Ruiz was thinking almost the same thing.

Her shift ended at seven, but she stayed two hours later to complete her report. She reviewed her bodycam first, then requested Maddox's footage. The first forty seconds made her sit back in her chair.

Leonard's hands were visible when Maddox arrived. They remained visible when the first command was given. There was no clear moment where he reached toward the cane. There was no command to drop a gun, despite what Maddox had already told a lieutenant verbally after the incident. Most troubling was the takedown itself: Leonard was already on both knees when Maddox drove him forward.

Ruiz rewound the video three times.

At 14:07:18, Leonard said, "I'm disabled. I've had a spinal injury."

At 14:07:22, Maddox said, "Get down."

At 14:07:26, Leonard's left knee touched the pavement.

At 14:07:30, his right knee followed.

At 14:07:32, Maddox's boot came high onto Leonard's upper back.

Two seconds separated compliance from force.

Ruiz began writing.

She wrote that Leonard's hands were visible. She wrote that a folding mobility cane was recovered behind the truck. She wrote that she did not hear Leonard threaten anyone. She wrote that she observed him on the ground with Maddox's foot placed high on his upper back near the base of the neck.

At 9:14 p.m., Lieutenant Paul Mercer appeared in the doorway.

"Still here?"

"Finishing the report."

Mercer leaned against the frame. "Maddox says the guy was noncompliant and made a furtive movement toward what he believed was a gun."

Ruiz looked at him. "That's not what the camera shows."

Mercer's expression barely changed. "You don't need to litigate the whole incident in your narrative. Just document what you personally observed."

"I am."

"Then maybe avoid words like stomp or neck unless you're certain."

Ruiz had not used the word stomp.

She looked at him more carefully. "I wrote that his foot was placed high on the upper back near the neck. That's what I observed."

Mercer exhaled. "Elena, you know how these things go. If you write it like that, Professional Standards has no choice but to open a force review."

"Then they should open one."

News in the same category

A Cop Forced a Disabled Man to the Ground — Then the Bodycam Showed His Hands Were Up

10 Part